pmchugh wrote:The beauty here is we can always avoid a no lynch by threatening to kill as a deadline approaches.

How is that beauty? Sounds like utter chaos at deadline time to me.

The vote on "???" does not count because "???" is not a player. The "???" vote is controlled by a player, but is not a player itself. Vote player controlling ???
Would I let you lynch the mafia by posting vote mafia ? I don't think so.
So you're implying that this mysterious double voter is scum ...

Yer proddin the hammer of my gun
J/k, I just dislike day one, there's no real logical course of action, obviously there are no suspects since you're bandwagoning me, and I'm reluctant to hop on my own bandwagon despite the evidence it would create.
Unvote
Sorry I'll post more.
You don't post ...

I'm thinking we might not have a doc in this game seeing as how captain was killed last night. Seriously, what doc wouldn't try to protect a claimed cop?

If there is a doc out there, I'm not trying to draw you out, just be a little smarter next time.

Yeah, so now that we have thoroughly ...

It will be mighty tempting to get revenge on colton when i can kill, for lynching me TWICE without allowing me to defend myself.

For now i will settle for a BW.

unvote vote colton.
Why kill him if he's not even playing? Your vote makes no sense. COlton is being replaced and your vote serves no ...

i could be wrong but an insane cop gets guilty for town and innocence for mafia, a paranoid cop gets guilty for everyone.

Right, an insane cop could investigate himself on night 1 and find that if he is guilty, his sanity is either insane or paranoid.
Do any cops actually do this though? Most ...

It will be mighty tempting to get revenge on colton when i can kill, for lynching me TWICE without allowing me to defend myself.

For now i will settle for a BW.

unvote vote colton.
Why kill him if he's not even playing? Your vote makes no sense. COlton is being replaced and your vote serves no ...

Great one walrus. Although you were nuts, you still served the town well.

And welcome back, LSU. We must have a reviver somewhere in this game. It's a good revive too. We need all of the investigative roles we can get.

Announcement

Rule Addendum: Given that the grace period is almost over and not everyone has posted yet, you may NOT kill anyone who has not posted unless I have prodded them.

Continue with day. With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch.
So who have you prodded. I would love to kill colton right now ...

captainwalrus wrote:

spiesr wrote:Note: colton got a one week ban on the second, so don't bother waiting for him...

A whole week without colton? w00t

Ok so say the mafia godfather is lynched. The mafia can't talk right? Can the mafia still kill?
From my experience, even without the godfather, the mafia would still be able to kill and talk. Although I guess a mod could make it different, I've never played in a game where the mafia wasn't able to ...

confirm

*takes aim at teh walrus*

Is pmc gonna defend himself at all? He doesn't seem like the one who stays quiet...

Ok, I am a cop and last night I investigated PMC. The result I got was "guilty" I don't know what that really means, but that is my result.
I wanted to be able to not claim, but build a case against him but he has been quiet. That is unusual for PMC but I didn't think that was good enough. I didn't ...

Ok, I am a cop and last night I investigated PMC. The result I got was "guilty" I don't know what that really means, but that is my result.
I wanted to be able to not claim, but build a case against him but he has been quiet. That is unusual for PMC but I didn't think that was good enough. I didn't ...

Hmmm, at what point is it considered to be claiming?
can you just like say yes or no as we guess roles?
Are you a cop? If he is actually telling the truth, then I doubt there will be any loophole around it. And I doubt a cop would have this sort of restriction. I'm guessing that his role is ...

I would back you as a mod you seem to know enough about mafia
Thanks, but I think I will wait a few games like Ace suggested before I do try to start my game. I don't want to start it and then have it sit there for weeks while no one joins. Thanks for the support though.

if you have experience ...

but not enough to deserve my vote just yet.

colton24 (5)- pmchugh, safariguy5, cowboyz, gregwolf121, Squirrels Hat
Darn, I keep forgetting that I don't control my own vote. I don't like how colton is now at L-1 so quickly. This bandwagon seems awfully scummy to me. And I'm starting to think ...

I don't know if this is the right place to post questions on mafia, but I will anyway.

Do you guys have any sort of restrictions on who can mod a game? I was recently talking to an old friend of mine (who I used to play mafia with) and we were discussing some of the wacky roles that popped up in ...

Darn. Fircoal never joined. I wanted to get revenge on him for shoot-em-up mafia.

unvote vote colton seems he is making stuff up
I don't know. Trying to weasel your way out of a fake-claim is one thing, but we never asked for a claim to begin with. He just came out and told us he wasn't able to. On the other hand, the role itself doesn't seem to make any sense. Why would a mod ...

Ok, a vanilla townie on a specifically non vanilla mafia game? That's an out and out lie.

My vote stands.

I think he means that he would turn to vanilla if he claimed.
Is that part of his role, or is he just confused? I've never heard of someone becoming vanilla upon claiming.

For all of you ...

gregwolf121 wrote:so theres three players and a mod right now

unfortunately.

AceArtemis wrote:cowboyz hasn't read my PM yet, but his online status is hidden, so I don't know if he's online or not.

ditto and hat, would you play a 4 player game if I make it nightless?

Sure.