Page 1 of 2

Best maps **Nominations**

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 2:34 am
by Iliad
Nominate a map into one of these category:

Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Classic: 4
Ireland: 1
Italy: 1
Great Lakes: 1
Europe: 2
Cairns Coral Coast: 1
Middle East: 1
North America: 2
World 2.1: 4
USA:1
Carribean Islands: 1
Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
Doodle Earth: 2
Age of Merchants:5
Middle Earth: 4
Tamriel: 1
Doodle earth:1
Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
Alexander's Empire: 3
Ancient Greece: 3
Circus Maximus: 1
Mongol Empire: 1
Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
Space: 3
USApocalypse: 4
Extreme Global Warming: 1
Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
8 Thoughts: 4
Crossword:1
King of the Mountains: 4
CCU: 2
War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Battle For Australia: 1
Pearl Harbour: 5
WWII Eastern Front: 2
Siege: 3

After there are enough nominations the voting will start for the best map in each category.

Here is the entire list of the maps:Real Geography (27 - Deserves 2 or 3 Nominations)
Africa,
Arctic,
Asia,
Australia,
BeNeLux,
Brazil,
British Isles,
Cairns Coral Coast,
Canada,
Caribbean Islands,
Classic,
Europe,
France,
Germany,
Great Lakes,
Hong Kong,
Indochina,
Ireland,
Italy,
Middle East,
Montreal,
North America,
Phillipines,
Portugal,
San Francisco,
USA,
World 2.1


Fictional maps (8 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
*Age of Merchants,
Discworld,
Doodle Earth,
Middle Earth,
*Siege,
Tamriel,
*Valley of the Kings


ONCE (Historical) and FUTURE (Space/future) - Deserves 1 Nomination
Historical maps (5)
Alexander's Empire,
Ancient Greece,
Mongol Empire,
*Valley of the Kings

Space/Future (3)
Extreme Global Warming,
Space,
USApocalypse


Historically War-related (7 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
Battle For Australia,
Battle Of Actium,
D-Day: Omaha Beach,
Pearl Harbor,
*Siege
WWII Eastern Front,
WWII Iwo Jima,


Abstract/Unclassified (8 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
8 Thoughts,
*Age of Merchants,
Chinese Checkers,
Crossword,
King of the Mountains,
Rail USA,
US Senate,
*Valley of the Kings
CCU
Circus Maximus


Post here if you think any of these categories are wrong?

NOTE: If a map qualifies for multiple categories (signified by the *), you may only submit it as the nomination for ONE category.

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 2:50 am
by Visaoni
Well, I think this one deserves a fair shot. Classic! :roll:

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 2:51 am
by Iliad
Visaoni wrote:Well, I think this one deserves a fair shot. Classic! :roll:

What a surprise!

Re: Best maps **Nominations**

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 3:38 am
by rebelman
Nominate a map into one of these category:

Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Ireland

Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
Age of Merchants

Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
Circus Maximus

Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
USapocolypse

Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
Crossword

War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Pearl Harbour

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 3:49 am
by Elwar
Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Classic

Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
CCU

Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
Ancient Greece

Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
Space

Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
8 Thoughts

War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Battle For Australia

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 4:53 am
by Iliad
thanks guys, your nominations have been noted

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 5:32 am
by Gilligan
Nominate a map into one of these category:

Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Italy

Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
Middle Earth

Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
Alexander's Empire

Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
USApocalypse

Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
8 Thoughts

War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Pearl Harbor

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 5:45 am
by Iliad
Thanks everyone!


Why do I have a feeling this will grow to 10 pages by tomorrow?

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 6:20 am
by orion_
Nominate a map into one of these category:

Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Great Lakes (2nd: Europe)

Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
Age of Merchants (2nd: Cairns Coral Coast)

Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
no nomination

Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
no nomination

Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
King of the Mountains

War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Pearl Harbour

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 6:41 am
by Herakilla
who the heck said crossword? ugh

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 8:05 am
by rebelman
Herakilla wrote:who the heck said crossword? ugh


i did it and i think i made an excellent choice

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 8:41 am
by Rocketry
doodle earth for real world(?) i guess

Rocketry

Re: Best maps **Nominations**

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 8:54 am
by DiM
Iliad wrote:Nominate a map into one of these category:


After there are enough nominations the voting will start for the best map in each category.


please include in your post all the maps from each category not just some examples because at the moment people are voting wrong maps in the wrong categories. Cairns Coral Coast is not fictional. it's actually a portion of coastline in eastern australia.


Real geography maps:
Classic

Fictional maps
Age of Merchants

Historic maps
Alexander's Empire

Futuristic maps
USApocalypse

Abstract
None

War-related
Pearl Harbour

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 10:08 am
by Sven Hassel
Real geographical maps
Europe

Fictional maps
Age of Merchants

Historical maps
Mongol Empire

Futuristic maps
Space

Abstract
King of the Mountains

War-related
WWII Eastern Front

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 10:12 am
by cena-rules
Real geography maps(i.e Classic, Australia, Europe)
Middle east

Fictional maps(i.e Middle Earth, Discworld, Tamriel)
Tamriel

Historic maps(i.e Alexander's Empire, Mongol Empire, Ancient Greece)
Alexanders empire

Futuristic maps(i.e Space map, Extreme Global Warming, USApocalypse)
No vote

War-related(i.e Siege! WWII Eastern Front, Pearl Harbor)
Siege

Abstract(i.e 8 thoughts, the senate, crossword)
8 thoughts

PostPosted: Wed Oct 17, 2007 11:37 am
by firth4eva
where is doodle earth?

Re: Best maps **Nominations**

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 3:04 am
by Iliad
DiM wrote:
Iliad wrote:Nominate a map into one of these category:


After there are enough nominations the voting will start for the best map in each category.


please include in your post all the maps from each category not just some examples because at the moment people are voting wrong maps in the wrong categories. Cairns Coral Coast is not fictional. it's actually a portion of coastline in eastern australia.


Real geography maps:
Classic

Fictional maps
Age of Merchants

Historic maps
Alexander's Empire

Futuristic maps
USApocalypse

Abstract
None

War-related
Pearl Harbour

Yeah I'll try to post all the maps. Be aware taht some maps fit in more than one category so you can choose what category to nominate them into

Re: Best maps **Nominations**

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:11 am
by Aerial Attack
I'm going to try and break down which category each map belongs to.

There are 54 current maps of which:

Real Geography (27 - Deserves 2 or 3 Nominations)
Africa,
Arctic,
Asia,
Australia,
BeNeLux,
Brazil,
British Isles,
Cairns Coral Coast,
Canada,
Caribbean Islands,
Classic,
Europe,
France,
Germany,
Great Lakes,
Hong Kong,
Indochina,
Ireland,
Italy,
Middle East,
Montreal,
North America,
Phillipines,
Portugal,
San Francisco,
USA,
World 2.1


Fictional maps (8 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
*Age of Merchants,
CCU,
Discworld,
Doodle Earth,
Middle Earth,
*Siege,
Tamriel,
*Valley of the Kings


ONCE (Historical) and FUTURE (Space/future) - Deserves 1 Nomination
Historical maps (5)
Alexander's Empire,
Ancient Greece,
Circus Maximus,
Mongol Empire,
*Valley of the Kings

Space/Future (3)
Extreme Global Warming,
Space,
USApocalypse


Historically War-related (7 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
Battle For Australia,
Battle Of Actium,
D-Day: Omaha Beach,
Pearl Harbor,
*Siege
WWII Eastern Front,
WWII Iwo Jima,


Abstract/Unclassified (8 - Deserves 1 Nomination)
8 Thoughts,
*Age of Merchants,
Chinese Checkers,
Crossword,
King of the Mountains,
Rail USA,
US Senate,
*Valley of the Kings


Post here if you think any of these categories are wrong?

NOTE: If a map qualifies for multiple categories (signified by the *), you may only submit it as the nomination for ONE category.

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:19 am
by Iliad
Pretty good except:
CCU should be Unclassfied(I think) and Circus Maximus is abstract. And people can choose to nominate how many maps they wish to

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:24 am
by Coleman
I'm going to nominate D-Day and only D-Day in all categories it is eligible in.

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:30 am
by Iliad
Coleman wrote:I'm going to nominate D-Day and only D-Day in all categories it is eligible in.

You can only nominate it for ONE category

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:31 am
by Aerial Attack
Iliad,

I mainly did that so you could copy and paste it into the Original Post - to help people with the categories. You can then add the # of nominations in. You can edit whatever text you want (so, if you want to let people nominate a map across the board - your call). Those were just projections based on every 8 maps deserved a nomination. Once again, you can change how you like - it's your thread.

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 4:48 am
by Iliad
Aerial Attack wrote:Iliad,

I mainly did that so you could copy and paste it into the Original Post - to help people with the categories. You can then add the # of nominations in. You can edit whatever text you want (so, if you want to let people nominate a map across the board - your call). Those were just projections based on every 8 maps deserved a nomination. Once again, you can change how you like - it's your thread.

Sure thanks.

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 5:25 am
by Gilligan
Battle of Actium should go under historical maps.

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 5:27 am
by Iliad
Gilligan wrote:Battle of Actium should go under historical maps.

No. The War-related maps are Historically War-related maps. They have their own category