Fairplay:
5 Stars is someone who goes out of there way to keep a game balanced or leader in check
4 Stars would be someone who works well with other in situations like letting fort out of a area
3 Stars for someone who plays a normal strategy and covers there butt while not shitting on anyone else
2 Stars go to people who seems biased toward either attacking or not attacking a certain player
1 Star would be a suicider or some other BS player with no sense in attacks that just plays to lose & make game miserable
Attendance:
5 Stars when you play almost immediately after me, have missed no turns, took no longer then 3 hours From available turn
4 Stars for those that play very frequently never letting available turn last more then 6-12 hour & has not missed any turns
3 Stars go to players that play every 12-24 hours and have not missed a turn, nor wait till last 2 hours every turn
2 Stars are for the people who have missed a turn or 2 and or always wait till the very end of turn available to Play
1 Star if you are a serial deadbeater who only plays to time out or barely beat clock and has missed multiple turns
Attitude:
5 Stars is a chatty player who engages in cordial conversations a Honest player that plays & talks with integrity & honor
4 Stars for courteous players who give good luck and good games & may chat a little but not much and is never rude
3 Stars to those that remain silent the whole game & say nothing to reveal anything positive nor negative about there self
2 Stars whiny players who complain & maybe slightly rude but don't necessarily Cross lines nor show true poor sportsmanship
1 Star Poor Sports far beyond Whiners, that are belligerent & offensive, players who say things out of spite & a mean spirit
Teamwork:
5 Stars Great teammate always in sync with team moves, acts wisely for team with little or no verbal coordination
4 Stars Coordinates well and communicates good strategy is cooperative and flexible with Good tactical plays in a jam
3 Stars Communicates but not always is in sync but does try and work as a team with teammates while holding own position
2 Stars Does not communicate well and a hindrance to team because of this, Does not look out for team interests
1 Star Saboteur plays as if single game, does not communicate at all, attacks & injures teammates, does not help when able
These are just what I am using as a base criteria on my ratings all games are judged by that game but I find that this framework helps me distribute ratings fairly. What do the rest of you use when deciding how you rate some one? Do you have any basic things you use to gage players?
