No-role Mafia TOWN WIN!!!!

[fireedud]

Vote Count

Kwanton(2)Kiwi, TWO
Dito
Sam(1)Kwan
Mili
PCM (3) fir, mili, Dito
Dano
Fir
LSU
Ani(1)JooDoo
TWO(1) Dano
/
Dunc(7.5)Fireedud
Dito(1)PCM
Joodoo(3) sam
Kiwi(1)/

Fireedud(1)dunc
with 15 alive it takes >7.5 to lynch.

yea, I said I was lazy and it wasn't accurate, but now I fixed it.

[Ditocoaf]

Since day 1 = waste of time when nobody knows their role…

vote dunc …for the hammer‽

…does this mean I'm scum?

[fireedud]

Since day 1 = waste of time when nobody knows their role…

vote dunc …for the hammer‽

…does this mean I'm scum?

nope, IT also means you didn't hammer. HE still has 7.5 votes on him

[dunc_2007]

uh oh...

[dunc_2007]

on second thought, [Game]vote: Ani.[/Game]

[sam_levi_11]

u mean bold not...game

[dunc_2007]

u mean bold not...game

I did..but you can't edit in mafia, can you?

[william18]

You can EBWOP.

[pancakemix]

Sam edited! HE MUST DIE!

Vote sam

[nagerous]

Vote Danodukebb


Drinking is bad...

I like the rest of you don't have a role.

[The Weird One]

Vote Danodukebb


Drinking is bad...

vote nag for hypocrisy

[Ditocoaf]

Seriously:

wait... so since all roles are secret, there probably aren't any mafia... just maybe a few SKs? This is strange.

I say we randomly select someone and lynch them; we can't do anything until we've had a night. In fact, this game probably should have started with night. If nobody minds, I'll enter the list of names (including my own) into Random.org and select someone to lynch...

[Joodoo]

Instead of having 7.5 votes to end the day, why not just set up a time limit for the day and night so this can get going faster?

[sam_levi_11]

Seriously:

wait... so since all roles are secret, there probably aren't any mafia... just maybe a few SKs? This is strange.

I say we randomly select someone and lynch them; we can't do anything until we've had a night. In fact, this game probably should have started with night. If nobody minds, I'll enter the list of names (including my own) into Random.org and select someone to lynch...

as good a way as any, except if your name comes out you wont say you, and could make it up. but stil, who cares

[kwanton]

I'm going to disagree with dito on the random lynch thing.

According to the first post, we all have a night action, which means that we have the chance to discover our roles during the first night. Because we are playing completely blind, I'm going to advocate a no lynch now so that everyone can discover their role tonight and we can move on as normal tomorrow. As far as nightkills go, I'm guessing that there will be one or two: a vig/SK combo. The mafia's main advantage is not the nightkill as most people assume, but the fact that they are allowed to talk to each other during the night and coordinate their actions during the day. In a game where no one knows their roles, having a mafia team will put them at a tremendous disadvantage(agreeing with dito here). A SK or two working by themselves would make much more sense given the game setup. We can use this to our advantage though. A smart vig will never kill randomly, therefore I'm going to ask that if anyone's target gets killed, then do not send in anymore actions. You don't know if you're a vig or not, so don't kill unless you know its scum

Anyways, a no lynch makes sense in this situation. The main reason for random lynching on day one is to gather information, but there is next to no information to gather. Sure, we will get the role after the death of the lynchee but that won't do us any good since it will be completely random (unlike a normal game where you can at least guesstimate a person's role by how they react to the bandwagon whether they are the person being bandwagoned or one of the people bandwagoning.) And without a role, there will be no roleclaims to stop a bandwagon and no real way for someone to defend themselves short of metagaming.

I'm going to stick to my guns on the no lynch barring any unforeseen circumstances. If you guys do decide to lynch someone, I suggest you do metagame and lynch someone who will probably screw us up with newbiness or stupidity (not naming names )

THE KWAN HAS SPOKEN!

DO AS YOU WILL!!!

unvotes all around

vote no lynch

[kwanton]

ABWOP:

I'm guessing you all know this, but just in case, when lynching randomly there is a higher chance to lynch a pro-town. And since the lynchee doesn't know that they are pro-town they can't really defend themselves.

Just an addition to help drive my argument home

[Joodoo]

ABWOP:

I'm guessing you all know this, but just in case, when lynching randomly there is a higher chance to lynch a pro-town. And since the lynchee doesn't know that they are pro-town they can't really defend themselves.

Just an addition to help drive my argument home

Unvote
Vote kwanton for what he just said.

[pancakemix]

^^Kwan fell for my trap.

Seriously, Kwan's idea > Dito's idea. One thing to add to Kwan's post: If your target dies, that doesn't necessarily prove your role kills. If your target dies, I recommend that you target someone else the next night to be absolutely certain that you kill.

Vote No Lynch

[Ditocoaf]

Crap... I forgot No-lynch was even an option...

seriously, why haven't we done that yet?

unvote vote no-lynch

[The Weird One]

vote no lynch

It's only logical.

[Ditocoaf]

Hmm... before we get to a no-lynch, should we develop some sort of strategy for the night? Such as, we all target someone else, in a circle. That way, it'd be much easier to figure out who does what.

How about this? We each target the person below us on the alive list: I target Sam_levi, Kwan targets me, and JooDoo targets Kwan. That way, we might be able to tell who does what.

[danodukebb]

i suppose vote nonlynch

[KiwiTaker]

Vote no-lynch

[sam_levi_11]

ok, and dito's idea is good.

vote no lynch

[fireedud]

Vote Count

Kwanton(1) JooDoo
Dito
Sam
Mili
PCM (2) fir, mili
Dano(0)nag
Fir
LSU
Ani(1) dunc
TWO
/
Dunc
Dito
Joodoo
Kiwi(1)/


no lynch(7)Kwan, PCM, dito, TWO, dano, Kiwi, sam

with 15 alive it takes >7.5 to lynch.

No lynch is at -1