vtmarik wrote:2, The Ranting Gryphon wrote:Take away the guns and people will stab each other. Take away the knives and people will throw drano on each other. Take away the drano and people will beat each other with 18-inch dildos!
And who needs a weapon? What do you think Kung Fu is? What were a bunch of old chinese monks doing besides trying to figure out how to bounce a guy's head off the ground with enough force to kill him?
"Well, guns make killing easier." So does a Lincoln Town Car! A metal grill doesn't do much damage but if you stick a V8 behind it you can make a family of four eat 120MPH screaming death in less time than it takes to scratch your ass twice. You pick up a dozen things every day that makes killing easier.
When will you people realize that if you want stop the killing you have to stop the hate? Take all of that anti-gun money and put it into anti-violence instead.
I don't doubt if you take away guns - people will continue to find other ways to hard each other. If some one is determined to kill another peoson of course there are hundreds of ways to do it. But to allow people to routinely hold and carry a weapon whos sole purpose is to kill another human is madness! There's a big difference to people carrying a blade to people carrying a gun.
See
http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/ZimringReduceKillings.htm
Is Gun Control Likely To Reduce Violent Killings?
Frank Zimring, University of Chicago Law Review
"Chicago police records include data which permit useful comparison between serious knife and gun attacks and between knife and gun killings. (See Table 6.) For 1967, these data show:
2.3 times as many serious knife attacks were reported to the police as gun attacks.
Knives accounted for less than half the number of homicides that guns did.
The rate of knife deaths per 100 reported knife attacks was less than 1/5 the rate of gun deaths per 100 reported gun attacks.
These figures support the inference that if knives were substituted for guns, the homicide rate would drop significantly."
Also from other reasearch:
"Guns can be as much as four times as lethal as knives. Of course, part of this difference could be due to the intent of the attacker, that is, knife wound mortality could be low because many attackers deliberately inflict superficial wounds. So we should also compare mortality for multiple penetrating wounds to the torso, which would seem to indicate some serious attempt to kill. For these sorts of wounds guns are still 3-5 times as lethal. Finally we can check with mortality rates for wounds to the same body structure (e.g penetrating heart wounds). We see the same pattern once again."