I normally hate parsing out posts, but I'm going to do it here.
Phatscotty wrote:thegreekdog wrote:Phatscotty wrote:Greek, I notice you keep going on about "indoctrination", and that's fine. I just want to make sure we both understand, that is an opinion and it falls into the "how and why" it is that students leave college Liberal/more Liberal.
Do you have an opinion as to how or why it is students leave college more Liberal? Or do you disagree with that altogether?
I don't know because you haven't provided any evidence of whether students leave college more or less liberal. You keep referring to videos and books, but all you've done from an evidence perspective is post a PDF of a study that shows that there are more liberal professors than conservative professors.
I'm also waiting for an apology (especially considering I read that 76-page PDF looking for any evidence of the students being more liberal point). You haven't shown evidence of any of your points (in this thread). And the indoctrination point is from the other thread that you posted in. If you've changed your mind about that point of view, please do tell.
I have not changed my mind. There are college professors who do in fact make it their life mission to indoctrinate as many students as possible. There is indoctrination. I have witnessed it and one time went along with it for the grade and another time I didn't. But, of course that isn't true for every single person, or every single professor.
And this is anecdotal evidence that others have provided. I've provided anecdotal evidence from law school, for example. You have NOT provided any link to any study showing that this has been proven.
Phatscotty wrote:The only thing I missed in making the overall point "College turns out Liberals" is leave out a key phrase.
"Indoctrination.....
amongst other things"
The evidence I guess you are ignoring at this point was done in a survey that tracked college Freshman until their senior year. It found Students are overall more Liberal in their senior year. If that isn't a piece of evidence, then what is it?
I have an idea. Why don't you attempt to talk about this, and not about me.
The political scientist Mack Mariani and the higher education researcher Gordon Hewitt analyzed changes in student political attitudes between their freshman and senior years at 38 colleges and universities from 1999 to 2003. They found that on average, students shifted somewhat to the left
I think you are confusing the term "evidence" with the phrase "what Phatscotty posted." For the fourth (?) time here, I'm going to state that you did not provide evidence... no study, no link to a study, no video, no link to a video... indicating that a survey was done of college freshmen finding that students are overall more liberal in their senior year. You've merely said it was done. That's not enough for me. I need to be able to read the study to determine whether there are any flaws in it. For example, if the study exists, did the study asks respondents why they are more liberal? As another example, if the study exists, how many students were polled? As a third example, did the study answer the question of why there are conservatives who aren't swayed by liberal professores?
In order to adequately and accurately determine whether the conclusion has merit, I need the evidence. You haven't provided it, despite your many posts in this thread. I'm not just going to take your quoted language above and try to make an argument. I've already stated that "on average, students shifted somewhat to the left" is not really evidence supporting your rather strong indoctrination theories from the other thread. First, it's a conclusion. Second, it doesn't support your argument at all; if anything, it tells me that we shouldn't really care all that much if students shifted "somewhat to the left" "on average." Which reinforces my theory that this is all paranoid nonsense.
Phatscotty wrote:p.s. At least you admit that there are more Liberal professors than Conservatives. Now, if you can understand it's more like 10-1 in certain areas, and even as high as 33 Liberals for every 1 Conservative, we can stop trying to minimize the truth into "okay, so there are a couple more Liberal professors than Conservative professors"
I think "admit" is the wrong word. I held no conclusion or theory one way or another on what political persuasion professors are. Based on anecdotal evidence (my own), I found that I could not determine most of my professors' political affiliations, but where I could, they was a smattering of liberal and conservative. Also based on anecdotal evidence (again my own), I found that most of my law school professors were liberal. That's all been posted in this thread.
So, I read the study you linked to (the 76 page PDF). It survey more than 1,000 professors and asked them their political views. The result was that more were liberal than conservative (although more were moderate than liberal).
Phatscotty wrote:so let me summarize your point as I understand it. "18 year olds enter the most Liberal dominated institutions in America, stay there for 4 years, but that has no influence on 18 and 19 and 20 year olds"
See above in this post where I ased this question - Why are students more liberal? Is it because of their professors? Is it because of their peers? Is it because they want to bang strangers and experiment with illegal drugs?
I'll summarize my points for you (since you did a bad job):
(1) The study shows that more professors are liberal than conservative by a wide margin;
(2) You've provided no evidence showing that on average students are slightly more liberal (you posted the conclusion... not evidence);
(3) Your theory in the other thread about indoctrination is not supported by evidence.
(4) Your theory in the other thread about indoctrination is not supported by the conclusion (i.e. (2)) that you've provided.
(5) The conclusion you posed "somewhat more liberal on average" makes me think I shouldn't care about this issue.
(6) Anecdotally, my own experience has led me to conclude that the classes I attended in college were taught by professors that I could not classify politically and that classes I attended in law school were taught by liberal professors.
(7) Anecdotally, the liberal professors in law school had no effect on political persuasions of the students.