Incorrect feedback

by **hulmey** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 3:41 am

I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

by *manimal on Thu Jun 26, 2008 3:46 am

hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Stupid I know. people that arent your teammates can leave you teamwork ratings.

by **Bruceswar** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 6:36 am

hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

This is something I cannot seem to grasp. It seems like they should not be able to rate you unless they have been on your team. Just a guess is that it is too code intensive to do it any other way.

by **ctwong1** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 9:43 am

Bruceswar wrote:
hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

This is something I cannot seem to grasp. It seems like they should not be able to rate you unless they have been on your team. Just a guess is that it is too code intensive to do it any other way.

If I play a team game, I usually either leave that rating blank, because it won't count against you, or I base it off of what I see in terms of how they fort each other. If they make a good team, I will usually give them a good team rating.

by **wicked** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 8:24 pm

hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Anyone who's played in a team game with or against you can rate your teamwork. After all, they're sitting their watching your moves and coordination. It's often quite obvious when teammates aren't playing "together" and when they are.

by **edbeard** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 8:37 pm

numbers are just inferior to words for feedback. we knew it'd be this way coming into it. /randomshotatthesystem

I do agree that he can rate your teamwork even if he wasn't your teammate. But, it's somewhat common to see people give low ratings solely because that player lost a game.

by **hulmey** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 8:42 pm

wicked wrote:
hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Anyone who's played in a team game with or against you can rate your teamwork. After all, they're sitting their watching your moves and coordination. It's often quite obvious when teammates aren't playing "together" and when they are.

haha, well i was playing with Lovo, who can vouch for my team work. Another example of the ratings system failing again. This would never have happened with the old system
[-X

by **Molacole** on Thu Jun 26, 2008 8:51 pm

wicked wrote:
hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Anyone who's played in a team game with or against you can rate your teamwork. After all, they're sitting their watching your moves and coordination. It's often quite obvious when teammates aren't playing "together" and when they are.

how can you rate somebody based on their temas performance when you have no idea what their tactics were. Maybe they had reasons why they didn't do certain things that might look obvious to others. It's just a dumbass option that shouldn't be there. Unless you've played on their team you will have no idea how well they work with their teammates.

by **t-o-m** on Fri Jun 27, 2008 5:12 pm

someone gave me a 1* rating in attendance even though i played all my turns around 30 seconds after him on a casual game and it wasnt even rt!
i did accuse him of being a multi though

which it is pretty obvious tat he was.

by **Fruitcake** on Fri Jun 27, 2008 5:17 pm

hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Hmmmm...it does look like you deadbeated at the end of the game hulmey.

by **owenshooter** on Fri Jun 27, 2008 5:43 pm

Fruitcake wrote:
hulmey wrote:I got a 1 star from a player for team work and ive never played dubz against him. How on earth should that be possible?

ps...ive playd against him , but never with him. Furthermore, beat him once out of the 2 games

Hmmmm...it does look like you deadbeated at the end of the game hulmey.

no, no, no... don't let the facts interfere with this!! damn you, fruitcake!!! without that tidbit of knowledge, i am going to say that i find it absolutely idiotic that someone that isn't on my team can rate my team work. again, they have no idea what our strategy was or what we were trying to do, yet they can comment on it? often times, what may look like a dumb move to someone, is a trap they walk right into, and costs them the game... soooo, i'm going to get a 2 for team work because my team pulled something on them they didn't even realize was happening? ridiculous.-0

by **BadMoonRising** on Fri Jun 27, 2008 9:06 pm

The ratings are about attitude...and you seem to pride yourself on how bad yours it...So live it up!!!

Think of it as a golf score.

by **BRILOGIC** on Sun Jun 29, 2008 7:22 am

as u see teamwork rateing is not working u should not be rated by anyone but ur team mate not only that but if u leave it blank ur rateing drops!I know ur trying to do good here but as they say if its not brokeing dont fix it.

by **detlef** on Sun Jun 29, 2008 7:29 am

BRILOGIC wrote:as u see teamwork rateing is not working u should not be rated by anyone but ur team mate not only that but if u leave it blank ur rateing drops!I know ur trying to do good here but as they say if its not brokeing dont fix it.

Wow, where to start...

It's Sunday so I'll simply point out that leaving a rating blank doesn't lower somebody's score and leave it at that.

by **alster** on Sun Jun 29, 2008 5:16 pm

detlef wrote:
BRILOGIC wrote:as u see teamwork rateing is not working u should not be rated by anyone but ur team mate not only that but if u leave it blank ur rateing drops!I know ur trying to do good here but as they say if its not brokeing dont fix it.

Wow, where to start...

It's Sunday so I'll simply point out that leaving a rating blank doesn't lower somebody's score and leave it at that.

Indeed. And that's why one should always hand out 1-star ratings. It always feels good leaving a game knowing that you have contributed to lowering your opponents overall ratings. Bastards. :shock: