Foe For Foe

[ParadiceCity9]

Actually no. Just thought of something. Think of it as, if he had just put me on foe list because I made a lot of bad plays or something, I'd be fine with that. But his reasons for foeing me are why I foed him.

That help?

[ZeakCytho]

As far as I can tell (and I could be wrong) this is what PC9's argument is, laid out in a slightly more formal way:
Premise 1) It is "legal" to put someone on your foe list because of bad gaming strategies on their part
Conclusion 1) If someone puts you on their foe list, it is because you had a bad strategy
Premise 2) You did not have a bad strategy, yet you were put on someone's foe list anyway
Conclusion 2) The foeing was "illegal"

Now, this is slightly different than the situation PC9 laid out, in which the foe was retributive, but I don't think it makes that much of a difference.

However...I disagree with PC9's position. A player is free to choose who they want to put on their foe list, no questions asked. I don't happen to want to foe anyone, so I don't/won't. But if someone wants to foe me, they're free to. I'd like to know why, to see if I've done something wrong, but ultimately it's their decision to make, not mine.

[ParadiceCity9]

As far as I can tell (and I could be wrong) this is what PC9's argument is, laid out in a slightly more formal way:
Premise 1) It is "legal" to put someone on your foe list because of bad gaming strategies on their part
Conclusion 1) If someone puts you on their foe list, it is because you had a bad strategy
Premise 2) You did not have a bad strategy, yet you were put on someone's foe list anyway
Conclusion 2) The foeing was "illegal"

I wouldn't necessarily say only bad strategy qualifies a foe, but that's basically my basis for foe list, yes.

Maybe you can give some tips to owen on how to respond to an opinion.

[owenshooter]

I can't explain it anymore than I already have. It makes sense.

it obviously only makes sense to you, if you can't find a single person to agree with you here in this thread.. wait, i think somewhere around page 4 or 5 a guy jumped in and you seemed to think he was supporting your argument, but he wasn't!!! yeah, i can safely say that nobody has agreed with you in this thread... wow.. that is a shocker. again, trust me, this argument is beyond salvagable. no matter how many times you change what you initially wrote when you posted, you can not save this argument. short of admitting how ridiculous your initial post was, this argument has no hope of anyone agreeing with you.-0

p.s.-keep mentioning me in your responses... i hope the mods are still paying attention. you continually attempt to bait me, but you are just not clever enough...

Maybe you can give some tips to owen on how to respond to an opinion.

just a page ago you were whining to andy about how i perpetuate arguments by disagreeing with you!!

See like I said andy...he spurs the arguments. He responded to me. I'm not gonna respond to him to avoid any confrontation.

[ParadiceCity9]

Actually no. Just thought of something. Think of it as, if he had just put me on foe list because I made a lot of bad plays or something, I'd be fine with that. But his reasons for foeing me are why I foed him.

That help?

I don't suppose you read that?

[owenshooter]

keep quoting the things that make no sense... it will make us ALL see the error of our ways.. oh, paradice, show me the way... i am lost in this jungle of CC darkness...-0

p.s.-i think i see a windmill..
p.p.s.-that was a reference to an earlier reference which probably went over your head.

[trapyoung]

keep quoting the things that make no sense... it will make us ALL see the error of our ways.. oh, paradice, show me the way... i am lost in this jungle of CC darkness...-0

p.s.-i think i see a windmill..
p.p.s.-that was a reference to an earlier reference which probably went over your head.

flaming outside of flame wars, well i thought i'd never see the day.

[Sentinel XIV]

keep quoting the things that make no sense... it will make us ALL see the error of our ways.. oh, paradice, show me the way... i am lost in this jungle of CC darkness...-0

p.s.-i think i see a windmill..
p.p.s.-that was a reference to an earlier reference which probably went over your head.

flaming outside of flame wars, well i thought i'd never see the day.

You're a little late to the show.

[daydream]

I added that little part about me foeing after being foed, but not for being on the foe list in case that person came in and said that I did that, which is the only time I have foed after being foed. But if you actually read my last post, you'll know it wasn't in return for being foed, as you seem to think it was.

you said many times now already that it indeed WAS for being foed... how does that work out?

No I didn't respond to him, I responded to him posting, not to his post. And to owen (the PM), I never said your post was a confrontation. I was just pointing out to andy that you were the one who potentially cause a confrontation. I never intend for my posts to become big arguments, but you make them that with your rude and hurtful posts.

this totally sounds like the foe'ing thing all over again lol
although admitadly it makes more sense.

[Sentinel XIV]

No I didn't respond to him, I responded to him posting, not to his post. And to owen (the PM), I never said your post was a confrontation. I was just pointing out to andy that you were the one who potentially cause a confrontation. I never intend for my posts to become big arguments, but you make them that with your rude and hurtful posts.

That is still a response to him. He posts something, and you respond to his act of posting. You're using the same reasoning for your Foe List argument. You're not putting someone on your Foe List because you're on their list, but because of the act of them putting you on their list? Either way you look at it, you're putting them on your Foe List because they put you on theirs. This is like trying to argue the meaning of the word 'is'.

[owenshooter]

i am still really confused by all of this. has anyone figured out what exactly this kid is talking about? it just really makes my head hurt to try and figure this all out. maybe he can try again... i really want to understand what he is saying, but it is just non-sensical to me... anyone?-0

[ParadiceCity9]

It's different for foeing someone for just being on their foe list than foeing someone who foed you for dumb reasons.

That's all I have said. It's quite easy to understand. Owen, reading comprehension..again..

[owenshooter]

It's different for foeing someone for just being on their foe list than foeing someone who foed you for dumb reasons.

That's all I have said. It's quite easy to understand. Owen, reading comprehension..again..

OOOHHHH... that makes perfect sense... to you. i still don't get it. it still makes no sense to me.. and you can't try to get me on reading comprehension, we both know you are the one that has difficulty with the written word. this thread/concept still makes no sense.-0

[ParadiceCity9]

It's different for foeing someone for just being on their foe list than foeing someone who foed you for dumb reasons.

That's all I have said. It's quite easy to understand. Owen, reading comprehension..again..

OOOHHHH... that makes perfect sense... to you. i still don't get it. it still makes no sense to me.. and you can't try to get me on reading comprehension, we both know you are the one that has difficulty with the written word. this thread/concept still makes no sense.-0

If it makes no sense, then you obviously have trouble with the most simple things in life.

[owenshooter]

If it makes no sense, then you obviously have trouble with the most simple things in life.

nobody in this thread agrees with you or understands you!! don't be obtuse, admit you are wrong.-0

[ParadiceCity9]

If it makes no sense, then you obviously have trouble with the most simple things in life.

nobody in this thread agrees with you or understands you!! don't be obtuse, admit you are wrong.-0

I'm not wrong. That would be lying.

[ParadiceCity9]

Wait a second..I even said on like page 3 that it was resolved as a matter of opinion. You can't bring this thread up again and tell me to admit I'm wrong.

[owenshooter]

Wait a second..I even said on like page 3 that it was resolved as a matter of opinion. You can't bring this thread up again and tell me to admit I'm wrong.

*rolling my eyes*... i feel like someone needs to throw a telethon for you...-0

[ParadiceCity9]

Wait a second..I even said on like page 3 that it was resolved as a matter of opinion. You can't bring this thread up again and tell me to admit I'm wrong.

*rolling my eyes*... i feel like someone needs to throw a telethon for you...-0

?