zarate2 and zarate3 [Busted]

by **Darthvadar** on Sat Apr 18, 2009 10:31 am

zarate2 and zarate3

The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis

Game number(s):

http://www.conquerclub.com/game.php?game=4703666

Comments: joined the same day, take turns together, maybe a coincidance

by **sailorseal** on Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:01 am

They only play dubs together so they might be friends

by **soundman** on Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:18 am

Darthvadar wrote:Acussed:
zarate2
zarate3

The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis

Game number(s):

Game 4703666

Comments: joined the same day, take turns together, maybe a coincidance

Form filled correctly.

by **king sam** on Sat Apr 18, 2009 3:47 pm

Aright here we go:

First of sailor two brand new users that join the same day from the same country with identical names and you would throw out this:

sailorseal wrote:They only play dubs together so they might be friends

Ive seen you report people for a lot less then all the coincidences we have here.

On to the data:
The only games these 2 have played in together were teams games, but that's besides the point.
All Freestyle except the one Noted.
Game 4703666
Game 4673878
Game 4652422 SEQ
Game 4647564

Easy way to do this is to see if their turns are overlapping in the Freestyle games, this 98% of the time will prove to be two users as while there are ways and techniques out there to have 2 accounts and use them at the same time more often then not it doesn't happen.

It looks very apparent that they try to give off the notion that its 2 users as their turns are simultaneous with each other, but the time difference has a gap that would lead one to believe this could be the same user logging in/logging out of accounts to continue the turn along. In these Freestyle games I did come across 2 turns that were real close together which could lead you to believe this is 2 users or 1 user that is able to manipulate the system to look like 2. Here that is:

Game 4647564 Log wrote:2009-04-12 03:41:44 - zarate3 deployed 3 troops on Veneto
2009-04-12 03:41:47 - zarate2 receives 3 troops for 6 regions

A 3 second time difference between the 2 users does take some skill/know how to pull of if this is one user

In the same game I found this though, which leads me to believe this could be the same person:

Game 4647564 Log wrote:2009-04-13 03:42:41 - zarate2 missed a turn
2009-04-13 03:42:41 - zarate3 missed a turn

Neither one of them talk in Game Chat, and they both have above 50% win ratios, this is definitely suspicious.
And will need an IP check to resolve.

Good Luck,
KS