Moderator: Community Team
btownmeggy wrote:qeee1 wrote:I think Catcher speaks a certain truth, that has not found such beautiful or genuine expression anywhere else in literature, and to dismiss it because the main character is too angsty is a great tragedy. It's like dismissing Don Quixote for being too detatched from reality. Salinger's other works are also great, but Catcher is truly his master piece.
The angstyness is not my main gripe with Catcher in the Rye. I DON'T find Holden relateable, likeable, or even compelling. He's not written as a character whose distance from the reader improves the story. It seems to me that he's meant to resonate within you, withstanding his foibles and goofs, but he certainly does not resonate within me.
"Brave New World" by Aldous Huxley
Frigidus wrote:but now that it's become relatively popular it's suffered the usual downturn in coolness.
hecter wrote:I thought I'd leave a suggestion of my own after reading all this. Lewis Carols books and poems are good for a light read. He wrote Alice in Wonderland. It's actually really good, so don't dismiss it because it's been Disneyfied.
Genghis Khant wrote:
Non sci-fi, check out Iain Banks' (without the 'M') The Wasp Factory.
MeDeFe wrote:And anyone who has a sound literary background (i.e. has read a lot of books) and a sense of humour should enjoy Jasper Fforde immensely. Even if you don't get even half of the jokes you'll still be laughing your ass off.
qeee1 wrote:btownmeggy wrote:qeee1 wrote:I think Catcher speaks a certain truth, that has not found such beautiful or genuine expression anywhere else in literature, and to dismiss it because the main character is too angsty is a great tragedy. It's like dismissing Don Quixote for being too detatched from reality. Salinger's other works are also great, but Catcher is truly his master piece.
The angstyness is not my main gripe with Catcher in the Rye. I DON'T find Holden relateable, likeable, or even compelling. He's not written as a character whose distance from the reader improves the story. It seems to me that he's meant to resonate within you, withstanding his foibles and goofs, but he certainly does not resonate within me.
if you can't relate to holden in any sense, then I guess you're not going to like the book, but if you can't relate to Holden, I dunno, that reflects badly upon you in my opinion. Em yeah, hate me or dismiss me for saying that if you like, but it's what I think.
.
areon wrote:Some serious books I finished reading were Biohazard by Ken Alibek and The 48 Laws of Power by Robert Greene. The first deals with biological weapons research and the second on how to make and destroy enemies to benefit yourself.
Incandenza wrote:areon wrote:Some serious books I finished reading were Biohazard by Ken Alibek and The 48 Laws of Power by Robert Greene. The first deals with biological weapons research and the second on how to make and destroy enemies to benefit yourself.
Can't help but throw a Studio 60 quote out there (in regards to the 48 laws of power book or whatever it's called): "It's a book for people who've never heard of Machiavelli."
It's just 'The Prince' with a hip-hop veneer. Do yourself a favor and read some Machiavelli, who had a bit more at stake than the average wannabe rap impresario.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users