jonesthecurl wrote:You missed out Essex Ed, from Turtleback Zoo. he said "more winter"... and A "Seahawks Victory". Apparently.
I didn't even know about Essex Ed, but after doing a search of his stats, I would not have included him even if I did. I checked four different compilations of famous groundhogs and basically included those who appeared on two or more lists. Essex Ed did not appear on any. Furthermore, like Balzac Billy, he is a fake, which would have led to his exclusion in any case. (Balzac Billy appeared on three of the four lists, but as you can see he did not get on mine due to being a fake groundhog.)
I also excluded groundhogs who were clearly overmatched by regional rivals. Thus, Brandon Bob did not make the list because Winnipeg Willow is clearly more popular in Manitoba media circles. The dominant groundhog in the New York / New Jersey region is definitely Staten Island Chuck, so Essex Ed would have been excluded on regional dominance grounds even if he was not already excluded for general lack of fame
and for fakery. So, on three different grounds he would not have made the cut.