Game of Thrones Mafia 9/24 Night 6: End Game Vote 4 MVP

[pretender77]

Also does that mean anyone from that location is now cleared of being mafia?

well that would mean there are only 4/24 scum, so we don't think so. 8/24 scum would be way too much though. I guess a town or 2 have 2 scum. If not a scum, probably an anti town third party (white walker?). But I don't think that storr has spread scum/anti town evenly otherwise it would be too simple. we don't trust each other in the dread fort unfortunately.

Maybe ....we have a minimum of one scum per town. That's puts us at 4 scum.
And then a minimum of 1 3rd party per town. That's puts at 8/24 scum
Like you said that would be wayyyy too much UNLESS we have like one 3rd party vig/sk and then some other role and Like a recruiting mason type role that doesn't have too much power besides the ability to recruit.
In that scenario 8/24 would not overpower

[pretender77]

Duh, because I told you so!
Regarding everyone that is wanting to know how I can for sure be Town...
I said somewhere up in all these pages that I thought Betiko or MTam were scum.

You'll quickly find out that I'm not very good at lying. I figure telling the truth is much easier to keep straight.

I still think we have another scum in DF to flush out.

you are definitely 100% a cleared town, congrats!

I hope that's sarcasm...Because He is not clear in my book

[betiko]

Duh, because I told you so!
Regarding everyone that is wanting to know how I can for sure be Town...
I said somewhere up in all these pages that I thought Betiko or MTam were scum.

You'll quickly find out that I'm not very good at lying. I figure telling the truth is much easier to keep straight.

I still think we have another scum in DF to flush out.

you are definitely 100% a cleared town, congrats!

I hope that's sarcasm...Because He is not clear in my book

given that I replied this a couple of posts earlier:

Hey, Zerg what is with the THRONE vote?
Who is that?
Someone has some explaining to do???

Not sure which color is to ask a question, or font, or whatever...

Hey, Zerg what is with the THRONE vote?
Who is that?
Someone has some explaining to do???

And if anyone else wants to explain, then please do!!

Ask him who are the remaining mafia! He can probably help us a lot on that too (as long as we put the right colour)

I'm sure you can find the answer!

[pancakemix]

As I stated earlier, I would say that we should not count on an even distribution among towns for anti-town parties. On top of that, we also should not presume to rule anyone out (i.e. Dread Fort)

[pretender77]

As I stated earlier, I would say that we should not count on an even distribution among towns for anti-town parties. On top of that, we also should not presume to rule anyone out (i.e. Dread Fort)

always a safe bet to play safe...the thing that is very interesting to me is that Dreadfort is so so public. By that I mean that many Dreadfort residents are known, as well as a Mafioso from dreaddfort has been killed. We know nothing about the others, especially The Throne. How much power does that entail Hopefully its just that invisible vote

[jwiedlin]

I think it is very likely that there is still a 3rd party or mafia in the dread fort, so we can not clear everyone in the dread fort of suspicion.

There are 4 players left in the dread fort, and I am not in favor of trying to flush out scum there at this point, given that our odds might be only 1 in 4 of choosing correctly.

[betiko]

As I stated earlier, I would say that we should not count on an even distribution among towns for anti-town parties. On top of that, we also should not presume to rule anyone out (i.e. Dread Fort)

always a safe bet to play safe...the thing that is very interesting to me is that Dreadfort is so so public. By that I mean that many Dreadfort residents are known, as well as a Mafioso from dreaddfort has been killed. We know nothing about the others, especially The Throne. How much power does that entail Hopefully its just that invisible vote

I m sure you can name more players from braavos still alive than from the dread fort.
Storm s end is the only one with 6/6 unknown.

[jak111]

I think it's safe to assume, that mtam was lying with who he swapped N1.

But why did he say he swapped me with someone? That seems like such a random thing for a lie.

So far nothing said while I slept peeked my interest. Sometime tonight we'll find out what the night had in store for us.

But since Charm is asking odd mod questions, it can't hurt to TRY to get a few questions answered while we wait for the results of the night.

1.) What happens when everyone from a city is eliminated?
2.) How does the Iron Throne move among the cities?
3.) If I die tonight can I watch the game progress in the QT's?

[Nebuchadnezer]

As I stated earlier, I would say that we should not count on an even distribution among towns for anti-town parties. On top of that, we also should not presume to rule anyone out (i.e. Dread Fort)

always a safe bet to play safe...the thing that is very interesting to me is that Dreadfort is so so public. By that I mean that many Dreadfort residents are known, as well as a Mafioso from dreaddfort has been killed. We know nothing about the others, especially The Throne. How much power does that entail Hopefully its just that invisible vote

Indications are that it's held by town or third party. I'm sure a mafia is not using a secret vote to kill his team mate. So let's not have Crasp reveal anything, yet. I guess the dreadfort citizens were a little more belligerent than the other towns. While I want to know who is where, I can be content for now with only knowing my town.

[StorrZerg]

1.) What happens when everyone from a city is eliminated?
2.) How does the Iron Throne move among the cities?
3.) If I die tonight can I watch the game progress in the QT's?


1. (sarcasm) I suppose the city turns into harrenhal and all players become ghosts... (/sarcasm) Serious answer, cannot confirm or deny
2. cannot confirm or deny
3. If you are a dead player, you will be told the answer of what you can do.

If you want to ask questions i will answer. Please do not waste my time on questions that do not pertain to the on going game. (fyi last question was off topic)

[legionnare]

I think it is very likely that there is still a 3rd party or mafia in the dread fort, so we can not clear everyone in the dread fort of suspicion.

There are 4 players left in the dread fort, and I am not in favor of trying to flush out scum there at this point, given that our odds might be only 1 in 4 of choosing correctly.

A good point, but remember there is doubt that the mafia/3rd party are spread evenly. Also of the 4 left in DF only 2 are known whereas we know of 4 in Braavos and none alive in King's Landing or Storm's End.
On a side note about the THRONE vote, could it be that because the vote has such potential power it's vote is decided by majority within the city it is held? Rather than held by one particular person?

[StorrZerg]

45 mins for night actions to be sent in
Day post 1 hour after that

[jwiedlin]

As I stated earlier, I would say that we should not count on an even distribution among towns for anti-town parties. On top of that, we also should not presume to rule anyone out (i.e. Dread Fort)

always a safe bet to play safe...the thing that is very interesting to me is that Dreadfort is so so public. By that I mean that many Dreadfort residents are known, as well as a Mafioso from dreaddfort has been killed. We know nothing about the others, especially The Throne. How much power does that entail Hopefully its just that invisible vote

Indications are that it's held by town or third party. I'm sure a mafia is not using a secret vote to kill his team mate. So let's not have Crasp reveal anything, yet. I guess the dreadfort citizens were a little more belligerent than the other towns. While I want to know who is where, I can be content for now with only knowing my town.

We cannot assume that the Iron Throne is not held by Mafia. By the time we saw a vote on mtam from the Iron Throne (8th vote, 5 hours left), it was already extremely likely that mtam was the lynch for the day.

At this stage in the vote, the Iron Throne vote was symbolic, and did not influence the decision. The person behind the vote might have been scum, and was wanting to establish a voting history that showed scum hunting.

We need to view this vote with the same skepticism that we would any player that voted for a mafia lynch. Yes, its encouraging, but no, it is not absolute proof of the intentions of the voter.

Legionnare brings up a good point too. Maybe the vote needs a majority consent of a city to be cast. That would explain the late vote by The Throne.

[strike wolf]

Just wanted to say. That was excellent reasoning Jwied. The odds on the throne being town have certainly gone up but we cannot eliminate that this was a fake out to gain town cred for laer.

[betiko]

I think it is very likely that there is still a 3rd party or mafia in the dread fort, so we can not clear everyone in the dread fort of suspicion.

There are 4 players left in the dread fort, and I am not in favor of trying to flush out scum there at this point, given that our odds might be only 1 in 4 of choosing correctly.

A good point, but remember there is doubt that the mafia/3rd party are spread evenly. Also of the 4 left in DF only 2 are known whereas we know of 4 in Braavos and none alive in King's Landing or Storm's End.
On a side note about the THRONE vote, could it be that because the vote has such potential power it's vote is decided by majority within the city it is held? Rather than held by one particular person?

Hum this is a possibility. When you talk of cities do you mean the 4 cities we know, or is the special QT a city too? I don t know though, I would think one person takes the decision and I don t really think people other than crasp know who holds the throne. I would guess lord varys is in the game too and has a similar power than crasp/littlefinger?
Anyway, the throne seems to be in good hands right now given how he voted, hope it won t change hands.
Fp

[pretender77]

I think it is very likely that there is still a 3rd party or mafia in the dread fort, so we can not clear everyone in the dread fort of suspicion.

There are 4 players left in the dread fort, and I am not in favor of trying to flush out scum there at this point, given that our odds might be only 1 in 4 of choosing correctly.

A good point, but remember there is doubt that the mafia/3rd party are spread evenly. Also of the 4 left in DF only 2 are known whereas we know of 4 in Braavos and none alive in King's Landing or Storm's End.
On a side note about the THRONE vote, could it be that because the vote has such potential power it's vote is decided by majority within the city it is held? Rather than held by one particular person?

Hum this is a possibility. When you talk of cities do you mean the 4 cities we know, or is the special QT a city too? I don t know though, I would think one person takes the decision and I don t really think people other than crasp know who holds the throne. I would guess lord varys is in the game too and has a similar power than crasp/littlefinger?
Anyway, the throne seems to be in good hands right now given how he voted, hope it won t change hands.
Fp

Does it really matter though who has the throne as it's only an extra vote?

[betiko]

Just wanted to say. That was excellent reasoning Jwied. The odds on the throne being town have certainly gone up but we cannot eliminate that this was a fake out to gain town cred for laer.

Well, I don t know enough details, but the idea I have of all this is that who holds the throne is anonymous and isn t sure to keep it.
If there is just crasp who knows who is on it, he can be easily discredited and we could have loads of wifom there. I don t think it would be a smart move for mafia to cast an anonymous vote on mtam, he was far from a lost cause at that point with all the no lynch votes.
We are pretty much in the dark regarding this anyway, we don t know if tomorrow the same person will be on the throne and who is that person.

[StorrZerg]

1 hour till day post
actions are locked

[StorrZerg]

Day 3: Would she Bang him?

The moon slunk behind a cascade of clouds and the night became dark. Margaery Tyrell was restless and could not sleep. She decided to go for a stroll in the gardens. Her footsteps echoed across the corridors of the seemingly vacant castle. The air was cool, but seemingly thick. She looked up to see the moon was no longer visible and the lumination it had provided dropped significantly. She decided to continue on walking. Small whispers began to float across the night air behind her and she became very anxious. She began walking very swiftly and there was a cocophony of sound behind her, other sets of footsteps and more whispers grew rampant. Margary turned opposite and the night fell still and deadly silent. A small patch of fog rolled towards her and formed into a cleaver above her. She began to run but the fog sliced at her. Her leg was cut visciously and she screamed out in pain falling to the ground. A loud set of footsteps thundered in the distance drawing nearer. The fog sliced and hacked at Margaery until she lay lifeless in a pool of her own fluids. The footsteps finally closed the distance to the scene and Stannis Barathian let out a loud gutteral sound as he saw the corpse being chopped at by the figure in the fog. He drew his sword and said "Today is the day one of us will die, and it won`t be me." He leapt into the fog with his greatsword poised behind him ready to strike. The fog consumed him and suffocated him and when everyone awoke....there were two bodies in the courtyard gardens.

show

Voting is open, please submit votes by 7/6 16:00 cc time

[jak111]

If the scene is any indicator, one person killed TWO people. (Someone in some fog) Either that or Jonty made both him and HotShot lovers.

That is not good news for us. Although why do the scenes keep hinting toward White Walkers?

Anyone wishing to share some info as of yet?

[betiko]

"You may watch 1 house per night". Holy shit how many secret QTs are there in this game???

[jak111]

"You may watch 1 house per night". Holy shit how many secret QTs are there in this game???

I missed that part, was looking at win condition more (3rd party yet can win with town basically). I assume "House" means city?

[betiko]

"You may watch 1 house per night". Holy shit how many secret QTs are there in this game???

I missed that part, was looking at win condition more (3rd party yet can win with town basically). I assume "House" means city?

I see it as baratheon, stark, lannister and so on... Storr always said city when he meant city.

[StorrZerg]

Treat any comments of "house" as "location"
fixed the mistake in day post

[HotShot53]

Well, guess I don't need to worry about keeping up with this over the 4th of July weekend now... good luck to town!