blackdragon1661 wrote:TA1LGUNN3R wrote:A new challenger approaches!
And it's an idiot...
Pay particular attention to the phrase "the total energy of the system is constant."
-TG
SO you believe that something can be made from nothing?
The problem is that you're attempting to apply an incomplete logic to nature, and there is a disparity between the logic of humanity and the logic of nature (or reality).
Using logic in everyday science and engineering is all well and good, but you must keep in mind that our math and rules that we set for a frame of reference is just that, a reference and not wholly encompassing of reality.
It's easy to say that the idea of a creator is a logical necessity. I can certainly see the logic there, but it's the logic built upon an incomplete knowledge. However, I agree with Hawking in that a creator is not necessary to the beginning of the universe, and here's why: 350 years ago, when Redi disproved spontaneous generation in his famous maggot experiments, it was a prevailng belief that maggots and therefore flies spontaneously came to be, as if from the aether. There was little knowledge of microscopic life, and the idea that life sized creatures can be borne from invisible matter was inconceivable to many. The history of biology is full of such examples.
And that's my point. Where the proponents of spontaneous generation or Lamarckian evolution or whatever other scientific theory that has fallen by the wayside went wrong is not that they were dumb, just that they operated upon conventional logic of the time and therefore could not imagine something which defied their incomplete logic.
If you had never learned about bacteria and viruses, would you believe some guy who told you that a invisible speck of an organism about a millionth of your size was responsible for your illness? Most likely you would not.
Similarly, while I may not completely grasp the finer points of the Big Bang Theory, I'm not gonna say it's wrong because it defies conventional wisdom. Experimental data certainly seems to support it, and it does not defy the laws of thermodynamics.
And besides, depending on God to create reality is a lazy cop-out--where did he come from? A paradoxical endless loop arises, and asserting that there must be a something to create applies to God as well.
So, tough titties and suck it up, cupcake. You're not the center of the universe.
-TG