Patches, waauw, Fruitcake, Dukasaur - calling all cars.

Moderator: Community Team
Pack Rat wrote:if it quacks like a duck and walk like a duck, it's still fascism
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=241668&start=200#p5349880
patches70 wrote:The ECB will no doubt attempt to pass the losses on to the taxpayers and the taxpayers will go along with it, that impulse should be discouraged IMO. Those holding Greek bonds deserve to get sent to the cleaners. They've contributed to years of economic torture and malaise upon the Greek people knowing full well that Greece entered into the EU in the first place by fraud.
mrswdk wrote:The Greek government lied to creditors and mismanaged its economy for years. It's now demanding that everyone else help it out of its mess. They deserve everything they're getting.
nietzsche wrote:i have no idea about what's happening, but i have a hunch that when everything is said and done, the richer will be richer and the poorer will be poorer. once again.
go on, discuss the details, the ending is the same as always. i bet the plot was already written by shakespeare.
GoranZ wrote:mrswdk wrote:The Greek government lied to creditors and mismanaged its economy for years. It's now demanding that everyone else help it out of its mess. They deserve everything they're getting.
Hmmm I totally disagree with this... explained with the following pictures...
In less then 10 years after Greece joined the EU its debt jumped from ~25% to ~75%(in 12 years from 25% to 100%). European institutions were giving much more money to Greece then it was able to repay. Someone really fucked up the job in those first 10-12 years and only Greeks can not be hold responsible. After that it was a matter of time when Greek crisis will explode.
According to me the creditors should lose all their money, they deserve that. And the reason is simple, so they will work more on where borrowed money are being used. If they are used for repaying old debts next thing that will follow is bankruptcy.
mrswdk wrote:nietzsche wrote:i have no idea about what's happening, but i have a hunch that when everything is said and done, the richer will be richer and the poorer will be poorer. once again.
go on, discuss the details, the ending is the same as always. i bet the plot was already written by shakespeare.
The lives of 'the poor' have got consistently better over the last couple of centuries. It's only because these people sit around comparing themselves to their society's richest 1% or 0.1% that they think their life sucks - if they were to compare their lives to those of their grandparents or great-grandparents, they'd see just how good they really have it.
waauw wrote:Greeced did 'officially' lie, however the other european countries knew they were lieing, which makes responsible as well.
The problem with Greece is that they used a lof of the money they received for mere expenditures rather than strong structural investments. Their social security system was out of proportion, illegal labour was allowed to run its course, the government had too many employees, etc. The truth is, Greece didn't even meet the requirements to join the eurozone and hence should have never been permitted.
GoranZ wrote:Bottom line... Even now Greece should pay 0(nothing) from its debt. Why? Because in order for things to be changed Europe must start from 0 with proper set of rules. If Greece pays its bills nothing will change and nothing will be learned by Europe. Better to "sacrifice" small country(if you can say it sacrifice) in order to learn something while there is time then to get burned totally from bigger EU member.
Atm Greece has two options:
1. If they continue to pay back their debt to get burned today, tomorrow and after tomorrow
2. To not pay their debt and to get burned today and maybe tomorrow but they will be much better after tomorrow.
P.S. I would chose 2.
GoranZ wrote:mrswdk wrote:nietzsche wrote:i have no idea about what's happening, but i have a hunch that when everything is said and done, the richer will be richer and the poorer will be poorer. once again.
go on, discuss the details, the ending is the same as always. i bet the plot was already written by shakespeare.
The lives of 'the poor' have got consistently better over the last couple of centuries. It's only because these people sit around comparing themselves to their society's richest 1% or 0.1% that they think their life sucks - if they were to compare their lives to those of their grandparents or great-grandparents, they'd see just how good they really have it.
You are correct but you are excluding many variables, way too many actually.
If we include the differences between rich and poor of our grandparents or great-grandparents times we will notice the real scale of the inequality in the world. And the word never seen such big inequality.
Greece should have bankrupted in 2008, since then a lot of its debt was in private investors... now it is in the hands of IMF or Europe's state hands. So in reality poor people will pay the bill for the mistakes of the rich people or corrupted governments.
Bottom line... Even now Greece should pay 0(nothing) from its debt. Why? Because in order for things to be changed Europe must start from 0 with proper set of rules. If Greece pays its bills nothing will change and nothing will be learned by Europe. Better to "sacrifice" small country(if you can say it sacrifice) in order to learn something while there is time then to get burned totally from bigger EU member.
mrswdk wrote:GoranZ wrote:mrswdk wrote:nietzsche wrote:i have no idea about what's happening, but i have a hunch that when everything is said and done, the richer will be richer and the poorer will be poorer. once again.
go on, discuss the details, the ending is the same as always. i bet the plot was already written by shakespeare.
The lives of 'the poor' have got consistently better over the last couple of centuries. It's only because these people sit around comparing themselves to their society's richest 1% or 0.1% that they think their life sucks - if they were to compare their lives to those of their grandparents or great-grandparents, they'd see just how good they really have it.
You are correct but you are excluding many variables, way too many actually.
If we include the differences between rich and poor of our grandparents or great-grandparents times we will notice the real scale of the inequality in the world. And the word never seen such big inequality.
So? These people should be happy that their lives are getting better, not whining that their levels of wealth and comfort are not growing at the exact same pace as richer people's.
mrswdk wrote:Greece should have bankrupted in 2008, since then a lot of its debt was in private investors... now it is in the hands of IMF or Europe's state hands. So in reality poor people will pay the bill for the mistakes of the rich people or corrupted governments.
How do you figure that? Public money = poor people's money?
mrswdk wrote:Bottom line... Even now Greece should pay 0(nothing) from its debt. Why? Because in order for things to be changed Europe must start from 0 with proper set of rules. If Greece pays its bills nothing will change and nothing will be learned by Europe. Better to "sacrifice" small country(if you can say it sacrifice) in order to learn something while there is time then to get burned totally from bigger EU member.
That's exactly why Greece should be required to pay its debt. Let Greece go belly up as an example to everyone else of what happens if you screw around.
And as waauw points out, if Greece says that it's not going to be paying the debts it owes then it is going to find it extremely difficult to find creditors in the future. No one wants to lend money to someone who's not going to repay them.
mrswdk wrote:It''s their fault too. Isn't that the whole point of Western democracy - all citizens play a role in running their country?
Greek people repeatedly voted for irresponsible governments and now they are paying the price for their irresponsible voting.
mrswdk wrote:That's exactly why Greece should be required to pay its debt.
waauw wrote: I think 'not saving Lehman Brothers' was evidence enough that how dangerous that plan is.
GoranZ wrote:mrswdk wrote:
So? These people should be happy that their lives are getting better, not whining that their levels of wealth and comfort are not growing at the exact same pace as richer people's.
I guess you didn't watch the video I posted... Watch it then we can talk.
Greece should have bankrupted in 2008, since then a lot of its debt was in private investors... now it is in the hands of IMF or Europe's state hands. So in reality poor people will pay the bill for the mistakes of the rich people or corrupted governments.
How do you figure that? Public money = poor people's money?
No, you are twisting my sentences to what you see fit...
Example:
-Before 2007 Greece was borrowing money from private funds/banks meaning the percentage of poor people's money in those funds was close to 0 if not equal to 0.
-Now after two debt reconstructions majority of the Greeks debt is in the hands of IMF/European governments... that literally means that poor people invested their money to save rich peoples funds/banks.
That is the difference.
Bottom line... Even now Greece should pay 0(nothing) from its debt. Why? Because in order for things to be changed Europe must start from 0 with proper set of rules. If Greece pays its bills nothing will change and nothing will be learned by Europe. Better to "sacrifice" small country(if you can say it sacrifice) in order to learn something while there is time then to get burned totally from bigger EU member.
That's exactly why Greece should be required to pay its debt. Let Greece go belly up as an example to everyone else of what happens if you screw around.
And as waauw points out, if Greece says that it's not going to be paying the debts it owes then it is going to find it extremely difficult to find creditors in the future. No one wants to lend money to someone who's not going to repay them.
Oh really? Are you sure that what you are saying is correct?
For example now Greece is borrowing money so it will return the money that they borrowed previously. If they dont have debt they wont be forced to borrow money in the first place. So in reality Greece wont need to borrow money so those "potential" creditors can put their finger where sun doesn't shine.
mrswdk wrote:Yes, if Greece had never borrowed money in the first place then they would not have debts to pay off. But they did, and they do.
patches70 wrote:mrswdk wrote:It''s their fault too. Isn't that the whole point of Western democracy - all citizens play a role in running their country?
Greek people repeatedly voted for irresponsible governments and now they are paying the price for their irresponsible voting.
This is a misnomer, it is also a stawman.
The voter has zero say on a central bank's policies and balance sheet. When was the last time the American voter voted about how the Fed operates?
If Greece goes through with its referendum it will be one of the first times in living memory such a thing has happened. Central Banks operate completely divorced from from the public yet it is the central banks that are the most important element of the global economic system.
That's exactly why Greece should be required to pay its debt.
is so laughable. Greece can't pay the money back.
mrswdk wrote:GoranZ wrote:mrswdk wrote:
So? These people should be happy that their lives are getting better, not whining that their levels of wealth and comfort are not growing at the exact same pace as richer people's.
I guess you didn't watch the video I posted... Watch it then we can talk.
cba. What's the gist of it?
mrswdk wrote:Greece should have bankrupted in 2008, since then a lot of its debt was in private investors... now it is in the hands of IMF or Europe's state hands. So in reality poor people will pay the bill for the mistakes of the rich people or corrupted governments.
How do you figure that? Public money = poor people's money?
No, you are twisting my sentences to what you see fit...
Example:
-Before 2007 Greece was borrowing money from private funds/banks meaning the percentage of poor people's money in those funds was close to 0 if not equal to 0.
-Now after two debt reconstructions majority of the Greeks debt is in the hands of IMF/European governments... that literally means that poor people invested their money to save rich peoples funds/banks.
That is the difference.
Wrong wrong wrong wrooooooong (to the tune of the Count Dracula song)
The public money being given to Greece is not 'poor people's money'. You think tax money only comes from poor people? And in any case, the IMF/EU money was being invested to stop Greece from collapsing, defaulting and making a messy exit from the Eurozone (i.e. it was to save Greece along with all the other countries tied to Greece).
mrswdk wrote:Bottom line... Even now Greece should pay 0(nothing) from its debt. Why? Because in order for things to be changed Europe must start from 0 with proper set of rules. If Greece pays its bills nothing will change and nothing will be learned by Europe. Better to "sacrifice" small country(if you can say it sacrifice) in order to learn something while there is time then to get burned totally from bigger EU member.
That's exactly why Greece should be required to pay its debt. Let Greece go belly up as an example to everyone else of what happens if you screw around.
And as waauw points out, if Greece says that it's not going to be paying the debts it owes then it is going to find it extremely difficult to find creditors in the future. No one wants to lend money to someone who's not going to repay them.
Oh really? Are you sure that what you are saying is correct?
For example now Greece is borrowing money so it will return the money that they borrowed previously. If they dont have debt they wont be forced to borrow money in the first place. So in reality Greece wont need to borrow money so those "potential" creditors can put their finger where sun doesn't shine.
Yes, if Greece had never borrowed money in the first place then they would not have debts to pay off. But they did, and they do.
patches70 wrote:Well, its now a pretty much done deal.
The ECB just announced that a Greek bank holiday will start on Monday. The ECB froze the ELA, so Greek banks won't get anymore money. Of course, the money showing in their deposits isn't actually in their banks so when everyone comes to get their money out of the bank there wouldn't be nearly enough physical cash to cover all the deposits (which is a true enough thing for virtually every single bank on the planet, if everyone tries to get their money out at the same time everyone will find out quickly that most of that money doesn't actually exist).
Greeks will be in the streets rioting, the ECB will never ever cancel the Greek debt, the Greek government will have no choice but to start printing Drachmas and the EU will have to figure out how to actually kick Greece out of the EU, which will be quite a feat since Greece can't be kicked out of the EU.
patches70 wrote:mrswdk wrote:Yes, if Greece had never borrowed money in the first place then they would not have debts to pay off. But they did, and they do.
Hey! Its not Greece's problem now, now its the ECB, EU, IMF and Germany's problem now isn't it?
Hahahahaha!
Greece says, "So sorry, we don't have the money to pay so screw you guys, we ain't paying the debt back" and they default. What happens?
Sure, people won't want to loan Greece any money in the near future. In return Greece gets out of their debt. Does this mean people won't still come to vacation on the Greek isles? Will Greece stop making wine? Will Greece stop growing pistachios, cotton, tomatoes, figs and almonds? Will shipping stop going through Greece? I doubt it. These things have real value and the money Greece makes from said resources won't have to go to paying the back the IMF (unless the rest of Europe wants to come in and take them by force, i.e. war, Europeans killing other Europeans, will it come to that?)
All these things are real wealth as opposed to the fake and arbitrary value of the currency "lent" to Greece. Greece has everything she needs to begin true economic recovery if she could only get out from under the crippling debt upon her.
patches70 wrote:Well, its now a pretty much done deal.
The ECB just announced that a Greek bank holiday will start on Monday. The ECB froze the ELA, so Greek banks won't get anymore money. Of course, the money showing in their deposits isn't actually in their banks so when everyone comes to get their money out of the bank there wouldn't be nearly enough physical cash to cover all the deposits (which is a true enough thing for virtually every single bank on the planet, if everyone tries to get their money out at the same time everyone will find out quickly that most of that money doesn't actually exist).
Greeks will be in the streets rioting, the ECB will never ever cancel the Greek debt, the Greek government will have no choice but to start printing Drachmas and the EU will have to figure out how to actually kick Greece out of the EU, which will be quite a feat since Greece can't be kicked out of the EU.
Users browsing this forum: WILLIAMS5232