Neoteny wrote:So I honestly still don't know. The slugs like McConnell and his ilk will still be happy to vote for the guy, but at a certain point some of this shit is going to start sticking to them in the eyes of the electorate. Is it worth it to force this through and get your court at the expense of their near- to mid-term electoral prospects? My gut says yes, they've accomplished a lot of their short term goals as a party already and getting this done will cement this term as an absolute massacre of the Dems.
On the other hand, there has to be at least a couple Republicans with some fragment of a conscience left, right? Or, at least they have enough self interest in holding a purple seat to cave on this? Statistically speaking, someone should break here.
The main problem is that Republicans are fast approaching, if not already past, the deadline where they would want to start shoving through a different candidate. In hindsight, they should have abandoned Kav from the first, and may have shot themselves in the foot by sticking with him so long. These nomination processes aren't quick.
I suspect there are a few different items in play:
(1) How will keeping or dropping Kavanaugh affect the mid-terms? If they keep Kavanaugh will it energize anyone other than Democrats? If it does not, and Democrats are energized, you get your Supreme Court confirmation but lose everything else. If they drop Kavanaugh will Democrats remain energized and/or will Republican voters be energized? In other words, does dropping Kavanaugh give the Republicans a bump in the mid-term elections?Related aside, I read a couple articles indicating that part of the frustration of Republicans is that a lot of conservatives don't believe polls saying the Democrats are likely to win and thus conservatives are unlikely to take the mid-term elections seriously. Fascinating stuff.
(2) How likely is it that dropping Kavanaugh results in the loss of a conservative seat? All polls show Dems taking the House and having a slim chance in taking the Senate. Those polls are getting worse for Republicans every day (because of Kavanaugh and despite economic prosperity). If pull Kavanaugh and lose the Senate, no more conservative Supreme Court. But if they pull Kavanaugh and keep the Senate, they get another shot. This is basically the opposite of what the Democrats are banking on.
(3) How will dropping Kavanaugh affect future nominations? The basic tenor of this whole scandal is: (1) Allegations of sexual assault are sufficient to prevent a Supreme Court seat (the first accusation); or (2) Being a frat boy or someone who drinks alcohol excessively as a young adult or white privileged teenager or football player or rich person or conservative Republican man is sufficient to prevent a Supreme Court seat (essentially the second and third accusations where the accusers are basically saying Kavanaugh either hung out with the relevant people or may have been at the party in question, but not sure but I heard it from one of my friends). This is disturbing precedent for Republicans and Democrats (but let's be honest that this kind of thing would never sink a Democrat-supported nominee) such that with (2) being a thing apparently that would disqualify a number of Republicans from holding any kind of high office. So if Republicans do not pull the nomination or vote against, they've put themselves in a precedent-setting position that they will pull the plug on nominations where any of the above factors are present. It's kind of like the 20-point psychopathy test but for judges.
My view is you vote down Kavanaugh (i.e. every Republican votes no) or you force Trump to pull him. Then you nominate the woman from Notre Dame immediately. Republicans will be more energized, you at least retain some semblance of respectability to women voters who are erstwhile Republicans or conservatives, and see what the Democrats do with that. You take your risk in the mid-terms, where you're still slated to keep the Senate for now.
In the interest of full disclosure, I think Kavanaugh played football, drank beer, and probably tried to hook up with high school girls and he was friends with guys that did those things and engaged in sexual assault. I don't believe that Kavanaugh committed sexual assault. The lesson I take away from this is be careful what you do and who you're friends with and with whom you choose to associate because it can come back to haunt you. I think kids nowadays really better be taking notes on this because the internet knows all.