Chubbatron/sea urchin [Cleared] Mas

[JCR]

Accused:

[player]Chubbatron[/player]
[player]sea urchin[/player]
[player]xxxxxxx[/player]



The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis or
Conducting Secret Diplomacy




Game number(s):

Game 10242599
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]


Comments:
I set up Game Game 10242599 which has yet to begin. I checked to see if it was filling. I noticed [player]Chubbatron[/player] had invited [player]sea urchin[/player] to the game which struck me as odd since it is an 8 man standard. I checked their games together. [player]sea urchin[/player]has 370 games total. 190 of these are with Chubbatron and 135 are non-team games. While they seem to span the spectrum of team games and standard they are, IMO, Multis or Friend/Family. If they are not mutils then they are obviously working as a team in their games. This cannot be construed in any other way than SD from my point of view.

I will be posting a link to this on their walls and asking them to drop the game.

[Chubbatron]

dude i didn't invite sea urchin at all in this game . I believe sea urchin is one of my friends cousins...who lives in Ottawa...i live in Thunder Bay. I do play with him often as he part of my regular rotation of players, i frequently play with.... as he is is on my friends list. so is Sprechen, and canadianbacon99. Now i demand a formal apology.

If you still have issues with situation, then drop out of the game/ add me to your foe list.

[Symmetry]

Accused:

[player]Chubbatron[/player]
[player]sea urchin[/player]
[player]xxxxxxx[/player]



The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis or
Conducting Secret Diplomacy




Game number(s):

Game 10242599
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]


Comments:
I set up Game Game 10242599 which has yet to begin. I checked to see if it was filling. I noticed [player]Chubbatron[/player] had invited [player]sea urchin[/player] to the game which struck me as odd since it is an 8 man standard. I checked their games together. [player]sea urchin[/player]has 370 games total. 190 of these are with Chubbatron and 135 are non-team games. While they seem to span the spectrum of team games and standard they are, IMO, Multis or Friend/Family. If they are not mutils then they are obviously working as a team in their games. This cannot be construed in any other way than SD from my point of view.

I will be posting a link to this on their walls and asking them to drop the game.

That's quite a range of accusations, to be fair. Can you provide any back-up evidence that they're "obviously working as a team"?

If you can provide some non-team game numbers for examples of obvious collusion, or secret diplomacy, this would have more weight.

[JCR]

I made the accusation and I did so in a direct way and also informed you of this report as I believe it should be done. IF they clear you I will apologize. IF they clear you.
I will let the Mods sort it out from here. If I am wrong, then I am wrong.
Also thank you for pointing out the connection between you and the others in that game. I will be dropping it.


There is no wide range of accusations. These accounts are either multis or friends working together in a consistent and repeated basis. It just smells wrong to me. Which is why I chose to let the people who have the tools to look into it, do so. if they so choose if not, so be it.
I believe 190 games out of 370 for one of the players is evidence enough. If they Mods want more, let them ask.

[Masli]

Cleared of being multis.
For the Secret Diplomacy, as you gave no games or moves to prove it, also cleared