Mandy wrote:6) Exile, I'm not disputing my mistake but HOW DO YOU PLAY FOR OVER A WEEK WITHOUT KNOWING YOUR WIN CONDITION?!?!

With ease, seeing as I just won

Thanks for running mandy, it was a really interesting game.

Is doom ever going to answer the questions asked of him? It's been 3 days.

After reading all this I'm still not so sure why people want doom lynched. He has a massive target on his back and it sounds like the only way trainers can win is if he isn't around so they will be targeting him tonight. So let's make this simple.

Vote : Dakky

You won't give up your boss, you ...

Go f*ck your self exile, you have no problem hammering someone but if I do it I am scum, you are my target tonight asshole
There's a world of difference in our approaches though. Someone EXPLICITLY SAID right above you that they were voting to put someone at L-1 IN ORDER TO GET MORE INFORMATION ...

I'm sorry for the delay, guys, I've been absolutely destroyed after New Year. And I've been missing some tasty reveals, apparently...

However, I cannot for the life of me understand why we would want Mewtwo around, James surviving or no. The town already has increased night lethality since all ...

(mitch stuff)
OMGUS vote here plus (and this is me being nicpicky) don't know why these two posts are an hour apart when you could have put them together.
This is a very good point. And the longer this goes on - especially with mitch admitting to killing someone, and with my suspicion mewtwo is ...

I KNOW psychic is not one of the wild Pokemon types, which is why I'm suggesting it would be a special role. Read that death scene again. Suicidal mind control. Purple glow around the eyes. Sounds like psychic interference to me, and the most likely character lorewise would be Mewtwo. Again, all I'm ...

What a fascinating scene, with a few surprises. this jumps out at me:

Poliwag was confused: “I thought that you Charmaders die if your tail is extinguished.”

“That is true, we do”, said Serbia. His eyes, Poliwag noticed, had a slightly violet glow. Serbia walked pass him and started wading into ...

Hmmmmm. I wasn't buying the case on fircoal, but after much consideration (i.e. thinking about it all day) I don't believe his Lapras claim. All the pokemon speculated on so far (eevee, vupix, pikachu) have evolution that would seem to match with the xp system, while Lapras doesn't. We could ask a ...

I don't buy the case on Fircoal and i'm too tired of this day 1 to avoid the clearly forming bandwagons. Unvote vote mitch.

Seriously, the whole "Make a deadline" things sounds to me like "Grampa Mandy, make us stop playing and send us to our room to study!" When I was your age, I didn't need anyone to send me to my room to study because back then we valued booklearning because the coal mine owner was just waiting for ...

Mandy, can I add my voice to those asking for a day 1 deadline? Doesn't have to be dramatically soon but I feel we are drifting either towards an apathy bandwagon to get it over or (worse) the game fizzling.

@ exile: If you are a Wild Pokemon, why did it take so long for you to ask about your victory condition? Shouldn't that have been one of the first things you asked for if it wasn't in your PM?
Should it? I saw I wasn't scum and basically autofilled that I would have a town wincon, or that I wasn't ...

Another thing to add is Exile has been trying to go after trainers the whole game - is it possible that the WC of trainers is to eliminate other trainers and take their recruited Pokemon to the end and eliminate team rocket? AKA cult, which has been speculated on before.
I may as well throw my ...

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him. In his PM, I believe Mandy made it unquestionably clear that X is the number of wild pokemon. The fact that you said you don't ...

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.
I knew it, I was just trying not to give away all the info I had in my PM straight off in day 1 . But here we are spelling out ...

I had a long post typed out and CC must have timed out my login. Ugh. Well, here;'sd the gist of it:

With Mandy's additional information, at least we're all on the same page (which I, obviously, was not previously, not having a wincon to compare to). It seems to me that the existence of wild ...

Alright, now we're getting somewhere!

The reason I say I suspect you of skimming is because I would imagine this is information which every player was informed of. Just by nature, it seems like a very important mechanic. I'm not saying what that reason is, just in case I'm wrong and not everyone ...

but it should be trivial to invent a pokemon name of an alternative, preferably without type advantage , so I'm not sure it holds up completely. Maybe we will get word of mod though.

There is a reason why this would not be trivial. The fact that you don't know why makes me think you are a skimmer ...

Tim's roleclaim (while silly and unnecessary) seems to indicate that there are loads of "third party" survivors in the form of wild pokemon, then. I still think that chasing trainers will lead us to scum, i.e. MM. I think that since tim didn't claim that wild pokemon are explicitly town as such (he ...

Hmm hmm hmm.

I can't agree with strike that speculating on day 1 arguments is more productive than either getting information on the roles through claims or forming theories on game setup. On the other han, I suppose we have a solid read on MM, so I'm willing to be convinced of another path, but ...

Oh and Exile, I am sure you have realised that you have basically acknowledged you are not a trainer right? sortof like what Masket did.

I do see what you're getting at, Skoff, but consider that trainers still want to get rid of other trainers to win the league, right? In fact, that seems to be ...

EBWOP

Unvote, Vote Minister Masket

The post you are refering too I explained how I got to those conclusions... if you need me to go step by step and quote by quote how I reached that conclusion, then sure, I can do that.
I'm going to point out that other people came up with similar conlusions/agreed because it makes sense.
I gotta ...

I gotta agree with Tim here, Nark. it dopes come across as you trying to say "hey, maybe i'm a trainer too" to MM with that comment. Which in turns make you ssupicious, because I'm wondering if the trainer deal is that they are actually cult or recruiting masons and they can "catch" (recruit) the ...