Best mafia game of all time(pre nomination)

[0ojakeo0]

POST THE MAFIA GAME IF YOU PUT OTHER!
super mario was mine.

[mandalorian2298]

Trying to choose between Sherwood and Godfather is making my head hurt. On one hand, Sherwood was probably the most innovative game ever, but on the other hand Godfather was more fun for me since I survived 'till the end.

As for nominations, I nominate Athkatla by Exile(first God mafia) and Bizzaro Mafia by AK_Iceman (I know that most people didn't like Ice, but that game was craziest game ever AND it functioned perfectly. And it had the most unlikely winners ever: Autoload (won by missinterpreting the concept and claiming scum) and I (won by being consistantly wrong about absolutely every element of the game )

[Fircoal]

In my baised opinion, I think the best ones listed so far are NV3, Sherwood, and Asylum. Also for it's lack of good active players @#$# in Mushroom Kingdom still ended up being pretty good. There are probably more games I need to think so. OFF TO THE ROLE SHEET!

And with my baised view I kinda think NV3 was a best, part because I modded it, part because it was truely awesome

[ga7]

Duh, forgot Athlaklaklak when Jake asked me about good games. ><
Anyway hard to pick, I liked a lot Kirby also. Mushroom kingdom was good but players messed it up too much

[ga7]

Ooh also Civil War by LSU. It had an original concept and ran awesomely

[william18]

What about Mass effect Mafia .

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Ooh also Civil War by LSU. It had an original concept and ran awesomely

qft hehe i did vote for sherwood though.

[pancakemix]

Of course, I had to vote my own game in the poll because I'm like that. But Batman was really good. Civil War I died too early to be a fair judge. Athklucklthala was pretty fun too. ALL HAIL MANDY!!

[Fircoal]

Anyway hard to pick, I liked a lot Kirby also. Mushroom kingdom was good but players messed it up too much

QFT, Kirby was fun to mod too.

No more votes/nominations for NV3?

[kwanton]

Civil war was fun, but my nominations go to Batman and Bad Poets Society (anyone wanna do another? )

[Joodoo]

I like No-Role mafia...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

sherwood and batman were probably my 2 favorite ones to play in while civil war was definitely my favorite game that I modded although the American Revolution game might pass it as I'm adding a few twists to use within the game. Still trying to finish getting it balanced though

[pancakemix]

So much mandy in sherwood...

[Iliad]

No-one nominates a game of mine?

I'll say batman.

[Skittles!]

Batman, probably. Though I died kind of early, I still enjoyed it a lot.

[Incandenza]

Sherwood was fun, but colaalone screwed the pooch for the scum, and we lynched moz on a technicality... on the plus side, it was extraordinarily innovative, mandy went insane, GT was perhaps the best vigilante EVAR (even tho he shouldn't have killed AK), and poor selin had to be a balladeer...

Weirdly, Bad Poets was the same way: great concept, but heinously awful play in the endgame.

So I'd vote for Bad Poets as the most creative game, but for pure anarchistic fun, nothing (for me) beat auto's 19-person game, my first chance to be scum.

[Sierra_Leon]

Ask this question again in 3 months or so.

[militant]

In my opinion Asylum mafia was the best I have played in on that list closely followed by Godfather

[Ditocoaf]

No Neighborhood Mafia option?

[nagerous]

When you say Super Mario, do you mean this classic or XG's game?

[sam_levi_11]

neighbour hood

[The1exile]

Woo, people mentioned Athkatla (well, they mentioned their various misspellings of it anyway ). Obviously I can;t vote for it, I didn't play in it, so I'm going with sherwood.

[Skoffin]

Vote neighbourhood

And that game I can't remember the name of right now.

[mandalorian2298]

Weirdly, Bad Poets was the same way: great concept, but heinously awful play in the endgame.

I resent the usage of the word 'heinously'.

Of course, I had to vote my own game in the poll because I'm like that. But Batman was really good. Civil War I died too early to be a fair judge. Athklucklthala was pretty fun too. ALL HAIL MANDY!!

Thank you my loyal servent. *drops 42 virgins in Pancake's front yard. Runs away before the neighbours can see him*

Ok, In the end I had to go with Sherwood. That concept is just a class of it's own. Plus, I have managed to annoy more people in that game then in all the other games combined.

[animorpherv1]

No Neighborhood Mafia option?

I nominate Neighrbourhood mafia!