supercram wrote:i'd say if y'all wanna kill me then do it. but after you find out it was wasteful, take a closer look at broom.
Thats a common mafia strategy.
there's far too many people in this game still for that to be an effective tactic if i was mafia. you would just come after me next turn if i told you to kill someone else and was wrong.
i'm not even voting for broom. i'm just saying, i think he came after me pretty strong for no reason.
so please, if you wanna, then vote for me. i know how this works. once you are on the chopping block, every single thing you say gets used as evidence against you. i play this game a lot IRL. so i can't just keep defending, it even looks guilty. whatever you're gonna do you're gonna do. but please, next turn. think about broom.
The first time I read Broomy's speech he seemed totally right, no doubt in my mind that he was protown. This also made me suspect supercram, because when you are sure that someone is protown, you tend to believe most of the stuff they say.
On my reread I started to question Broomy. Why is it so bad to want to know things about your fellow townies? If the mafia already know more than us and have info, then why would it be bad for the townies to gain some info? What exactly do the mafia know that the rest of the town doesnt?
I still think that supercram reacted way to strongly to Broomy's statement. Super- He wasnt calling you stupid, he only said that your idea was stupid. He also said that stupider ideas would come.
And I think that broomhead's vote was not to early or unwarrented, because of the way Supercram reacted.
Also on my first read through I thought that AK Icee was definetely town. He was having good ideas and contributing to the town, so why would anyone suspect him? On my reread I realized that I may have thought AK Iceman was good because Broomy said so. Now AK looks just like a regular townie again.
It is clear that already strong... relationships, are being formed. It seems that Broomhead and Iceman are on one side and supercram is on the other.
I feel the same way about broomhead, I feel I can trust him right now.
Machiavelli wrote:On my reread I started to question Broomy. Why is it so bad to want to know things about your fellow townies? If the mafia already know more than us and have info, then why would it be bad for the townies to gain some info? What exactly do the mafia know that the rest of the town doesnt?
I disagree with broomhead here though, the more the townies share about each other, the more opportunities there are for the mafia to make mistakes.
I see sharing info as risky, but necessary to finding the mafia.
I could go either way on Broom. Based on that post, he is good enough to pull off being mafia and throwing all that info out there. But would he be stupid enough to cast a vote so early to draw suspicion upon himself? Only time will tell I guess.
well i'm a f*cking hothead and you should all know it now. in fact some of you can visit the flame wars forum and find my posts to confirm. wicked, i know you're no stranger to it, Matser Bush is no stranger to it, nor is any Stache.
in my second post on this site, ever, i called andy a prick.
in this thread, we were all talking normally and then here comes broom telling me i'm stupid and AK is smart, and here's what we can expect, and here's how to play, etc. i got pissed off.
also i notice he said to me : "i want your response" and that he "would like" the opinions of others. this is leadership language, i am being commanded, and everyone else is beaing treated as a colleague. i just don't trust people who try to emerge as leader right away.
If people seriously go after him for it all he has to say is "I dont like being called a d*ckweed or being told F#CK you"
Broomy is a skilled player, it is usually the unskilled players that will jump on bandwagons. Good mafia players arent scared to be the first one to vote.
I have nothing to hide... I'm Andre Taylor, owner of the Rock Ridge Inn. Regular vanilla townie (nice term btw broomie!), which I'm finding a little anticlimatic after being mafia the last two games..lol. My inn was burned by the infected scum, so I'm pretty pissed about that!
