Best (Randomness) Of 2012 Game Over!

[Iron Butterfly]

confirm

[pancakemix]

Firm

[rishaed]

Falling FIRMly in place!

[soundman]

Confirm!

[jonty125]

Anyone seen [player]vodean[/player]??

Game will start tomorrow, with or without him.

[jonty125]

DAY ONE START!

Deadline is Wednesday 23 January, at 1600 GMT.

[DoomYoshi]

Vote vodean

A) major scummarine
B) he hasn't been on since before jonty sent out the PMs, but jonty didn't notice the pm was in his box, which means at least one other player got that pm.... Which means he is probably mafia.

[gregwolf121]

after applying my RSFFS, or Random Scientific Formula for Finding Scum, the results i got point to one man so i must vote kanin

[rishaed]

vote Doom he must be the mafia whose going to bring Doooooooom on all of us.

[Kanin Usagi]

after applying my RSFFS, or Random Scientific Formula for Finding Scum, the results i got point to one man so i must vote kanin

Your RSFFS makes me sad. =(
Vote doom for being too logical!

[spiesr]

B) he hasn't been on since before jonty sent out the PMs, but jonty didn't notice the pm was in his box, which means at least one other player got that pm.... Which means he is probably mafia.

Can you show me what post what led you to this conclusion? (The part about Jonty not realizing Vodean didn't open the pm himself.)

[Hank44Soccer]

I'll reserve

[thechuck51]

B) he hasn't been on since before jonty sent out the PMs, but jonty didn't notice the pm was in his box, which means at least one other player got that pm.... Which means he is probably mafia.

Can you show me what post what led you to this conclusion? (The part about Jonty not realizing Vodean didn't open the pm himself.)

yeah I didn't quite get that either. Jonty asked if anybody has seen vodean but i dont see how that gets us to Doom's conclusion

[crazymilkshake5]

If you vote for me you have a tiny penis!

[rishaed]

^You're gonna start the Pen!s votes again? Really?? Just after we get some decent conversation going? FOS CMS5

[Kanin Usagi]

If you vote for me you have a tiny penis!

I have a tiny penis. On Opposite Day. unvote, vote CM5!

[DoomYoshi]

If he didn't open the pm himself, it means he isn't on the site and not checking his inbox. Ergo, nobody has seen him, so why would jonty ask?

[crazymilkshake5]

^You're gonna start the Pen!s votes again? Really?? Just after we get some decent conversation going? FOS CMS5

it was my first post of the game D:

and also OMGUS Vote kanin

[DoomYoshi]

Ok. Two scenarios:
Scenario one: vodean doesn't open his message. Jonty First checks the timestamp and sees vodean has been gone for a couple weeks. I would think jonty wouldn't say anything in the thread.
Scenario two: the message is opened. Jonty wonders why vodean opened the message but isn't posting. He asks in thread why vodean isn't posting.

QED?

[spiesr]

Jonty, please replace Vodean. Even if he does come back he clearly won't be reliable at this point in time.
Vote DoomYoshi for advocating the lynch of an absent player at this point in the game.

[edocsil]

Ok. Two scenarios:
Scenario one: vodean doesn't open his message. Jonty First checks the timestamp and sees vodean has been gone for a couple weeks. I would think jonty wouldn't say anything in the thread.
Scenario two: the message is opened. Jonty wonders why vodean opened the message but isn't posting. He asks in thread why vodean isn't posting.

QED?

QEFail. Jonty sees PM is unopened and that vode is gone, posts in thread saying he will start even if vodean is not seen. Scene starts the game shortly after. Also, Scenario 2 doesn't paint him as scum. It would be unlikely that jonty was looking for vode just because he didn't confirm. He must have seen the unopened PM to notice it.

Source: Lots of modded games and the past times I have done the same thing.

[edocsil]

Ok. Two scenarios:
Scenario one: vodean doesn't open his message. Jonty First checks the timestamp and sees vodean has been gone for a couple weeks. I would think jonty wouldn't say anything in the thread.
Scenario two: the message is opened. Jonty wonders why vodean opened the message but isn't posting. He asks in thread why vodean isn't posting.

QED?

QEFail. Jonty sees PM is unopened and that vode is gone, posts in thread saying he will start even if vodean is not seen. Scene starts the game shortly after. Also, Scenario 2 doesn't paint him as scum. It would be unlikely that jonty was looking for vode just because he didn't confirm. He must have seen the unopened PM to notice it.

Source: Lots of modded games and the past times I have done the same thing.

Vote Doom for being hasty in conclusions

[jonty125]

Hank44Soccer replaces vodean.

[jonty125]

DoomYoshi (3) - rishaed; spiesr; edocsil
Kanin Usagi (2) - gregwolf121; crazymilkshake5
crazymilkshake5 (1) - Kanin Usagi

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch, as things stand a no lynch would be enforced.

Deadline is Wednesday 23 January at 1600 GMT.

[DoomYoshi]

Jonty, was my vote removed due to replacement or am I voteless?