[OFFICIAL] Charle's Fun Mafia - "Game On" Day 4

[DirtyDishSoap]

I would be looking closer at Sonic and asking questions, he was very quick to put me forward for a lynching without establishing any other reason that I was late coming to town. Most other commentators have been putting forward sensible discussion points so far

That's pretty Sonic to me. I think I've only played against scum Sonic once but so far this isn't unusual behavior.

[Ragian]

@halrob, I still don't understand why anyone should believe you to be town more than anyone else...

[Darin44]

@halrob, I still don't understand why anyone should believe you to be town more than anyone else...

sound like he trying to convince himself he town to me

[halrob64]

Ragian,
Why are you so important to be convinced? What is your vested interest in the towns welfare?

[halrob64]

Whats that bulge under your jacket Darin, not a gun is it??

[Maxleod]

Unvote.

Vote Hal

He's losing it

[Maxleod]

Unvote.

Vote Hal

He's losing it

[Ragian]

Right. So halrob has no intention of answering any questions pertaining to his gameplay, and now he's a L-2. Claim time, my friend. And make it swift, please, so we can get more out of this day.

[SoN!c]

Yes Halrob needs to claim. Why he has to was very well explained by Ragian a few posts back.

And Max who knows Halrob and Chana very well from GC stating "he is losing it" makes me feel there is something to find behind this Halrob facade..

[Ragian]

I don't like to hide behind other's assessments. It seems like dereliction of responsibility. As if you already know halrob's alignment, and you're already distancing yourself...

[Charle]

Vote Count:

Halrob (5) - Loose, Sonic, Darin, Chanakam, Max
Loose (1) - hjelp
Darin (1) - Kong
hjelp (1) - Devon

13 Alive - 7 Needed for a Lynch

[SoN!c]

I don't like to hide behind other's assessments. It seems like dereliction of responsibility. As if you already know halrob's alignment, and you're already distancing yourself...

Im talking about the rules. Not your assessment. Why a player needs to claim at L2. It's pretty obvious too. But feel free to bend my words

[SoN!c]

Now you made me look up a post for the second time Rigian

@chana, usually people claim at L-2 because putting someone at L-1 hightens the fear of a speedlynch (or maybe someone is hated townie; a role that requires a majority vote minus one). It is not mandatory, but it is customary. Not claiming at L-2 holds town hostage, so I'd always advocate lynching that person. If not, there's no reason for anyone to claim at any given point the rest of the game.

As for lying as a townie, there is an on-going discussion. Some people adhere to a LaL-policy (lynch all liars), while others - myself included - can see that a lie the right time for the right reason can be beneficial for town.

[Extreme Ways]

I don't like to hide behind other's assessments. It seems like dereliction of responsibility. As if you already know halrob's alignment, and you're already distancing yourself...

The bolded is either catered exactly towards pocketing me, or Rag is just town?

Expresses the same sentiment I had, just now targeted as just 1 player.

I am also voting Halrob in spirit but will not put him on L-1.

[Ragian]

And Max who knows Halrob and Chana very well from GC stating "he is losing it" makes me feel there is something to find behind this Halrob facade..

This bit is what I'm talking about. Why do you call that bending words? Are you not saying that you base your vote mainly on Max?

Fp'ed by EW

[Ragian]

I don't like to hide behind other's assessments. It seems like dereliction of responsibility. As if you already know halrob's alignment, and you're already distancing yourself...

The bolded is either catered exactly towards pocketing me, or Rag is just town?

Expresses the same sentiment I had, just now targeted as just 1 player.

I am also voting Halrob in spirit but will not put him on L-1.

Ahm...what does that mean? Pocketing you...

[Loose Canon]

YEP EW MY REACTION IS TO ECHO RAG
(I think)

EW your "voting Halrob in spirit but not putting him at L-1" couldn't make you sound more like you're caught deciding whether to go mafia on mafia with Halrob, if you tried.

[chanakam2020]

YEP EW MY REACTION IS TO ECHO RAG
(I think)

EW your "voting Halrob in spirit but not putting him at L-1" couldn't make you sound more like you're caught deciding whether to go mafia on mafia with Halrob, if you tried.

I guess we should give Hal a reasonable time to talk before putuung him to L-1 or L-0.
Because
Aftter he gone up to L-2 he still did not write any thing here and may be he has not seen his current status yet.

[halrob64]

Well there is no association with Mafia here, as far as I can see the ones who are aligning against me are most likely Mafia sheep following what the Don orders. I'm surprised at chan and max I thought they were upstanding citizens but clearly not

[Ragian]

Dude, claim your role to remove the heat.

[halrob64]

Ragian I am the law in this town so to you are either with me or against me

[DirtyDishSoap]

So, Cop or Sheriff. Thought he bread crumbed a lawyer or something.

[SoN!c]

Unvote

[Loose Canon]

That's quick though understandable sonic.
It could be a fake claim?

DDS what about saying I am the law would determine halrob is not claiming lawyer?
And I've missed why you might think he might have breadcrumbed lawyer.
Enlighten me on that and what you think a lawyer might do please.

[SoN!c]

That's quick though understandable sonic.
It could be a fake claim?

DDS what about saying I am the law would determine halrob is not claiming lawyer?
And I've missed why you might think he might have breadcrumbed lawyer.
Enlighten me on that and what you think a lawyer might do please.

Yes i need time to think. Also Halrob claiming cop is in line with what others said he was hinting a big PR. I got it wrong thinking it was just GC related.
So im wrong or its a false claim...but then Halrob is a dead man walking IF he claims town cop while being scum.

I would think a player getting the town cop role would not be lurking so long and posted his "awayness" in advance like Dev did.

Lots to rethink on