Page 7 of 32
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 8:02 am
by nagerous
The way I see it we can either lynch ga7 for being glutton the scum copier or fircoal for being lustful cult recruiter. Fir can only recruit people who are not one of the sins so if we don't lynch him quick enough I think his cult could possibly get out of control and overgrow. Hence vote fircoal. However, ga7 maybe a copier but he is in fact a scum copier (glutton), this is shown by the fact that when fircoal tried to recruit him he was unable to because ga7 was his own sin and fir can't recruit vanillas. The skoffin thing just seems like spam that we can ignore for now. Anyway:
Vote Fircoal before his lustful cult gets out of control.
We must lynch ga7 next however before he copies too many skills and gains too many powers resulting in the glutton being too powerful. If the cop wants to investigate him it may be sensible if you think my theories are too wild but I believe them to be wholely accurate from what I read.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 8:02 am
by nagerous
Lol I voted twice.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 8:50 am
by rebelman
ok the last few pages were "interesting" - i think nag's assessment is a fairly good one so I'm going to follow his lead
vote fircoal
also can we keep the chat on here instead of msn as its impossible to know what has been altered and not when you guys are posting it from msn.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:20 am
by ga7
Rebel, I think the only thing really concerning the game that was said on MSN was the Skoffin bit, that Kwan asked us to post.
Nag, I'll only agree about one thing: whoever feel free to investigate me, even though it might be a wasted one if there's a scum killer out there, it will be useful if there's again no kill.
It sounds to me like you got your head too full of your Heroes ideas

Taking aside the fact that despite voting for Fir you seem to completely buy his story and disregard the fact I had the choice to accept recruitment or not, if we go along with your out-of-nowhere theory that gluttony is a copier, wouldn't it be more like a thief, stealing powers from others? I can guarantee it doesn't work like that, nor do I accumulate powers. I just copy one dude and can use his power the next night (which means the coming night I can only try to copy someone again). It amazes me that you discard the whole Skoffin thing so easily too - it was no joke. I think I'll either target her or you for this statement.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:36 am
by nagerous
I would say target me because it will entertain you as it is a private joke but I don't want to give you another power haha I'm in heroes mode you damn glutton. I'd prefer you to target skoffin that way, even if you steal a new power it might give us another lead to find another sinner before we bring about your lynch. Why not buy fir's story he has no reason to lie, though he slipped up when he said he was a cult recruiter (him and his lust) but the fact remains that he could not recruit you because you yourself are a sinner!!!!
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:39 am
by kwanton
Vote Count:
fircoal (3) ga7, nag, rebelman
skoffin (1) fircoal
As for the MSN stuff I've told em to keep their arguments in the thread. Skoffin is just stupid.
10 to lynch. Carry on then.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:39 am
by nagerous
Fir has clearly given your game away and even if he is a cult recruiter, the fact remains that he can only recruit pro-towners and it failed hence you are not a pro-towner and your lynch and downfall will swiftly come (after Fir's of course) (lets bump the cult off first before it grows too strong).
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:45 am
by LSU Tiger Josh
VOTE FIRCOAL The 'chu is evil and evil must die.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:58 am
by ga7
nagerous wrote:I would say target me because it will entertain you as it is a private joke but I don't want to give you another power haha I'm in heroes mode you damn glutton. I'd prefer you to target skoffin that way, even if you steal a new power it might give us another lead to find another sinner before we bring about your lynch. Why not buy fir's story he has no reason to lie, though he slipped up when he said he was a cult recruiter (him and his lust) but the fact remains that he could not recruit you because you yourself are a sinner!!!!
Hah you peaked my interest, I'll target you then and you'll see you can STILL USE YOUR FREAKIN POWER! You raving loony

Then I guess it'll be a scum power so two birds with one stone so to say. For Fir I said my piece, he knew he was fucked and tried to get me lynched instead, now I just hope an investigation will clear me and the copying will condemn you scum! Man I need sleep.

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 10:59 am
by diddle
Well, this was certaintly a pleasant suprise. I'm not 100% sure who to vote for, although I'm thinking nothing of the Skoffin incident.....yet. Ga7 has defended himself flawlessly, but Fircoal seemed pretty adamant, and I can't help thinking why he would out himself like that if he was scum. It wouldn't be done, not by anyone in this game anyway. Despite that, I'm going to Vote Fircoal - I would be seen as uber-scummy if I was to vote for Ga7, as he's had someone cover for him.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 12:17 pm
by kalishnikov
Unvote, vote: Fircola It's been awhile since I've seen a good Fir bandwagon and this one has actually got proof/reasoning.
FOS: ga Of course when Fir's recruitment failed you're gonna say you had a choice to accept or not but I'm not buying it. I believe that it failed because your scum but Fir gets my vote as he seems to be the most 'dangerous' at the moment, the worst ga is gonna do is copy someone's powers.
And Skoffin definitly said 'I'm scum, but I'm not a liar' somewhere in that mess of 'chu/Frenchness.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 12:22 pm
by cena-rules
vote fricoal
ya u cult
me hate cult
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 1:17 pm
by kwanton
Vote Count:
fircoal (7) ga7, nag, rebelman, LSU, diddle, kalish, cena
skoffin (1) fircoal
10 to lynch.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 1:28 pm
by firth4eva
My interpretation of what could have happened:
Fircoal is cult/scum or something not good for us. He tried to get on our side because he found out ga7 was scum so he went to out him. I also think ga7 really is scum and only got to choose whether he was recruited by Fircoal was because he has been recruited by someone else.
So I am going to vote fircoal because we need to out him because I am pretty sure he is scum.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 2:17 pm
by Clive
Should have lynched ga yesterday...but yeh I think he should be lynched tomorrow...vote Fircoal
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 2:25 pm
by Fircoal
Ever well morons. You think I'm scum. well I'm not. Just remember, if you lynch me you lose a big chance. as shown my role is overpowered. Pity no one believed me.
As my last words, I'll say that Frenchie-chan, and Skoff are scum. Go after them. Though I think it's a moot point, as town as probably lost the game now.
Good going retards.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 2:33 pm
by Fircoal
also I must say re-visit some of my arguments. Most of it shows the truth. As I'm one away from lynch I guess this is it.
Anyway, there are some places where I edged it a bit to try to get vote on him. I'm well aware the sins probably aren't in a mafia together, so I lied when I said about him having gain in lynching me. I figured his role might work like a cult too.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 2:36 pm
by Clive
That sounds pretty sincere...For now, unvote
What is your exact role claim please Fircoal?
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 2:52 pm
by Fircoal
it just says preist. I have decided my life against the sin. Everything thing else I've basically said. I can't check my pm now. Cause I g2g.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 3:31 pm
by NESconqueror
After reading up, I am very thankful no kills in the night. I am not sure who to vote though, as I still have no leads.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 3:40 pm
by nagerous
NESconqueror wrote:After reading up, I am very thankful no kills in the night. I am not sure who to vote though, as I still have no leads.
Try reading.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 3:41 pm
by kwanton
nagerous wrote:NESconqueror wrote:After reading up, I am very thankful no kills in the night. I am not sure who to vote though, as I still have no leads.
Try reading.
Apparently NES is using a generic mafia post generator...

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 3:50 pm
by rebelman
thanks for that stunning input nes it helps a lot

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 3:56 pm
by rebelman
im not skoffin and dont know her very well but if this were my game i would make priest the winner if he survived because he would have been stronger than sin. so even if the claim is true and hes town we should kill him anyway as possibly sin has no power over him so scum cant kill him but he can be lynched - sorry if this sounds a bit daft but to me it ties in with what i believe the role to involve.
Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 6:03 pm
by kalishnikov
NESconqueror wrote:After reading up, I am very thankful no kills in the night. I am not sure who to vote though, as I still have no leads.
lol, wow... In the last 5 pages we've found 2 scum and a cult leader. Consider not skimming for once.
Seriously, wow.