Conquer Club

ga7 on the list of best mafia players? Clearly he paid someone off for the nomination....

Also, there is no such thing as a 'best' mafia player, there are only players who excel in certain situations/roles. In order to choose the 'best' anything there needs to be a set criteria to judge by, preferably a win/loss ratio or success/failure ratio. This poll is nothing but a popularity contest as is any poll in which you invite the public to vote based on absolutely zero prerequisites.

If you want to make a poll of the best players, do the research and list the player's win/loss ratios, number of games played, etc. and when you're done you won't need a poll, you'll have the answer to your question.

Incandenza wrote:This pole needs more Incandenza goodness. I'm like Sandy Koufax: brilliant but short career.

A perfect reason for you to get your ass back into the wonderful world of Mafia. Seriously Inca, are you going to allow the real world to run your life?

kalishnikov wrote:ga7 on the list of best mafia players? Clearly he paid someone off for the nomination....

Also, there is no such thing as a 'best' mafia player, there are only players who excel in certain situations/roles. In order to choose the 'best' anything there needs to be a set criteria to judge by, preferably a win/loss ratio or success/failure ratio. This poll is nothing but a popularity contest as is any poll in which you invite the public to vote based on absolutely zero prerequisites.

If you want to make a poll of the best players, do the research and list the player's win/loss ratios, number of games played, etc. and when you're done you won't need a poll, you'll have the answer to your question.

Blame Flores. She mentioned him.

kalishnikov wrote:ga7 on the list of best mafia players? Clearly he paid someone off for the nomination....

Also, there is no such thing as a 'best' mafia player, there are only players who excel in certain situations/roles. In order to choose the 'best' anything there needs to be a set criteria to judge by, preferably a win/loss ratio or success/failure ratio. This poll is nothing but a popularity contest as is any poll in which you invite the public to vote based on absolutely zero prerequisites.

If you want to make a poll of the best players, do the research and list the player's win/loss ratios, number of games played, etc. and when you're done you won't need a poll, you'll have the answer to your question.

I think I would win

Hey, thanks for the votes, but I'm sure that there are many other very valuable mafia players, some of them not even on the list. It's very difficult to select one of them as best mafia player.

By the way, who did nominate me?

.

I did since you're the best Selin

In the category of most active Vets, Fircoal should win hands down. I nominate THE 'CHU!

Nominate mandy

And would've skoff but it says active

mandalorian2298 wrote:In the category of most active Vets, Fircoal should win hands down. I nominate THE 'CHU!

Chu's been inactive for weeks.

I nominate myself.

jnd94 wrote:I nominate myself.

You're less than active yourself. The problem with this is, most of the real vets aren't playing right now. I'd say ga7 is the most active, at least in one respect.

pancakemix wrote:

jnd94 wrote:I nominate myself.

You're less than active yourself. The problem with this is, most of the real vets aren't playing right now. I'd say ga7 is the most active, at least in one respect.

WHAT!?!?! OF COURSE IM MOST ACTIVE YOU BITCH!!!

Nominate Iliad.

pancakemix wrote:

jnd94 wrote:I nominate myself.

You're less than active yourself. The problem with this is, most of the real vets aren't playing right now. I'd say ga7 is the most active, at least in one respect.

I can think of a bunch that are more vets than me though
Pancake, LSU, AD are the older actives I can think of right now.

pancakemix wrote:

mandalorian2298 wrote:In the category of most active Vets, Fircoal should win hands down. I nominate THE 'CHU!

Chu's been inactive for a week.

fixed.

Though overall, I should win. Being how I've been at least semi-active since I joined. I've pretty much been in a game all the time throughout me career. It just depends on what the poll is looking for. Most Active Vet now, probably not, but most active vet over history, I don't think there is anyone that can say I'm not. With being one of the oldest players (2nd to spiesr, since he came back again), playing the most games, and having a general record of always being there.

ga7 wrote:

pancakemix wrote:

jnd94 wrote:I nominate myself.

You're less than active yourself. The problem with this is, most of the real vets aren't playing right now. I'd say ga7 is the most active, at least in one respect.

I can think of a bunch that are more vets than me though
Pancake, LSU, AD are the older actives I can think of right now.

I'm so fickle, though. I just sorta drift in and out. Granted, that's for extended periods, but still...

Iliad wrote:Nominate mandy

And would've skoff but it says active

Thanks Illy. Too bad you won't forgive me my golfer joke.

Have no idea about who's been here long so I better not nominate, will gladly vote though.

I nominate myself.
I always stand at the front line of mafia, when I can.

I've been totally neglected.

Of course I haven't been playing much.