Page 11 of 11
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 4:42 pm
by Blitzaholic
Gilligan wrote:1. dcc1220 Sergeant 1st Class +560
2. Gilligan Lieutenant +635
3. Incandenza Corporal 1st Class +522
mixed us up
you forgot to mention which map?
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 4:44 pm
by Gilligan
CCU +596
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 5:15 pm
by Scott-Land
barterer2002 wrote:Do you want score updates on the ones that are already in there.
My World 2.1 has dropped slightly to 1035
Valley of the Kings is now at 564
I've added
Age of Merchants at 532
no Barter-- just post your high only as it's "all time high"
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 5:24 pm
by barterer2002
Fair enough, thanks scott
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 5:31 pm
by Nickbaldwin
Madness Captain 112pts for Major +888 Won 52 from 95(55%)
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Wed Aug 27, 2008 12:07 am
by Night Strike
[player]Optimus Prime[/player] is now at +809 on USA.
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Wed Aug 27, 2008 1:08 am
by Scott-Land
Hey guys Daydream will update this thread when he has more time- I'm picking up the slack until he returns then you can continue to post here.
New thread to update:
Top10 Individual Map RanksThanks....
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 8:19 pm
by FATHARRY
An update on the feudal war top 10.
I have searched through the 20 or 30 players that I know are good on feudal, including all on Daydream's current list. These are the top 10 by maprank from those I have searched. No doubt I have missed some players.
My feeling though is that map rank is not the best indicator of skill on a particular map. Compare for example myself (fatharry) with torter_of_worlds. He has a better win percentage than I do (82% vs 75%). He has also played stronger opposition than I have (avg opponents' rank 2103 vs 1803).
So why do I have a better map rank than he does? For two reasons. 1) I have played more games and thus had more opportunity to collect points. 2) My overall rank is lower than his, so I gain more points for beating the same opponent and lose fewer points for losing to the same opponent.
I therefore include here another statistic which I call "performance" and which I believe is a better measure of map skill. It is calculated as: performance = average opponents rank X sqrt (w/(1-w)) where w is the winning percentage. The motivation for this formula can be seen in my thread
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=59621. The performance can be viewed as what one's rank would be if one played only this map and no other.
Of course another flaw with both systems is they are based on one's entire playing history. Ideally we would want a measure that is based on recent performance e.g. last 30 games. Unfortunately the stats are not easy to collect until someone writes an appropriate gm script.
Name Map Rank Nett Points Performance
1. fatharry Field Marshal +4116 3142(5)
2. dapper tom Brigadier +2049 3319(3)
3. torter_of_worlds Colonel +1751 4481(1)
4. me-da-minority Colonel +1700 2229(7)
5. daydream Colonel +1678 1859(9)
6. domquebec Colonel +1529 2898(6)
7. thomas.paine Major +1488 3769(2)
8. army of achilles Major +1375 3178(4)
9. battle-rage Major +1230 1720(10)
10. zapusca007 Major +1022 2006(8)
Cheers,
Harry.
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 8:27 pm
by Scott-Land
FATHARRY wrote:An update on the feudal war top 10.
I have searched through the 20 or 30 players that I know are good on feudal, including all on Daydream's current list. These are the top 10 by maprank from those I have searched. No doubt I have missed some players.
My feeling though is that map rank is not the best indicator of skill on a particular map. Compare for example myself (fatharry) with torter_of_worlds. He has a better win percentage than I do (82% vs 75%). He has also played stronger opposition than I have (avg opponents' rank 2103 vs 1803).
So why do I have a better map rank than he does? For two reasons. 1) I have played more games and thus had more opportunity to collect points. 2) My overall rank is lower than his, so I gain more points for beating the same opponent and lose fewer points for losing to the same opponent.
I therefore include here another statistic which I call "performance" and which I believe is a better measure of map skill. It is calculated as: performance = average opponents rank X sqrt (w/(1-w)) where w is the winning percentage. The motivation for this formula can be seen in my thread
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=59621. The performance can be viewed as what one's rank would be if one played only this map and no other.
Of course another flaw with both systems is they are based on one's entire playing history. Ideally we would want a measure that is based on recent performance e.g. last 30 games. Unfortunately the stats are not easy to collect until someone writes an appropriate gm script.
Nett Points Performance
1. fatharry Field Marshal 4116 3142(5)
2. dapper tom Brigadier 2049 3319(3)
3. torter_of_worlds Colonel 1751 4481(1)
4. me-da-minority Colonel 1700 2229(7)
5. daydream Colonel 1678 1859(9)
6. domquebec Colonel 1529 2898(6)
7. thomas.paine Major 1488 3769(2)
8. army of achilles Major 1375 3178(4)
9. battle-rage Major 1230 1720(10)
10. zapusca007 Major 1022 2006(8)
Cheers,
Harry.
Heya Harry-- I'm just filling in for Daydream, but from what I see, the thread isn't an actual 'Map Rank'. It's just total amount of points won on a particular map. Maybe you're referring about the relative rank? Perhaps the title of the thread is misleading and should be changed- your thoughts Blitz?
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Thu Aug 28, 2008 8:38 pm
by FATHARRY
Fair enough - you can still update the points won list for feudal though, ignore the "performance" if you like
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 11:31 am
by xxtig12683xx
+1214...kid_a on circus
-tig
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2008 2:36 pm
by badlouie
I certainly don't crack the top 10 on Feudal, but at least I'm respectable!!
Feudal War9 Lieutenant88 +712 Won 74 from 222(33%) Won 18 from 46 207 Serial Killer (60%)223 Equalitarian (0.899)
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Sat Aug 30, 2008 2:41 am
by Scott-Land
Scott-Land wrote:Hey guys Daydream will update this thread when he has more time- I'm picking up the slack until he returns then you can continue to post here.
New thread to update:
Top10 Individual Map RanksThanks....
Please use the above link to post your scores- it will save me the trouble of going back and forth. Many thanks--
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 11:20 pm
by Humrlmo
Map Rank:
Age Of Realms 2 Colonel +1678
Age Of Realms 3 Colonel +1531
Edit:
Wow, did a map rank on
MageplunkaDoodle Earth Field Marshal +8025
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2008 11:02 pm
by Plutoman
Bamboo Jack + 826.
^^
Sorry for the bump, was reading through older threads since I haven't been here in a while <_<
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2008 11:19 pm
by porkenbeans
+583 Prohibition Chicago.
Re: Top 10 Map Ranks for each Map
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2008 11:41 pm
by blakebowling
Scott-Land wrote:Scott-Land wrote:Hey guys Daydream will update this thread when he has more time- I'm picking up the slack until he returns then you can continue to post here.
New thread to update:
Top10 Individual Map RanksThanks....
Please use the above link to post your scores- it will save me the trouble of going back and forth. Many thanks--