Conquer Club

Well if I'm to believe 5koffin/ET that leaves william18 and yorkiepeter. The only problem with that is william gave a very believable claim earliet..

Unvote for now since it seems I was wrong about the trackers and roleblockers thing

icedagger wrote:Well if I'm to believe 5koffin/ET that leaves william18 and yorkiepeter. The only problem with that is william gave a very believable claim earliet..

Unvote for now since it seems I was wrong about the trackers and roleblockers thing

Considering the strength of the town id be very surprised if the mafia didn't have a gf so phil inst auto cleared in my books.

Announcement

A deadline has been set.

You have until Thursday 9 pm (GMT) to come to a lynch.

icedagger wrote:Well if I'm to believe 5koffin/ET that leaves william18 and yorkiepeter. The only problem with that is william gave a very believable claim earliet..

Unvote for now since it seems I was wrong about the trackers and roleblockers thing

Wut's this? Feeling like you can't get either of us lynched now eh?
I still do not trust you. Iliad got lynched because 'we were aligning ourselves together', yet you and Will have done the same thing. Atleast our excuse was that I *investigated* him to know his innocence, what's yours?

I think atleast one of those two are scum, they could even possibly be scum buddies.

I've never aligned myself with will, he's followed me around a few times, which has annoyed me more than anything because it's just made me look scummy.

I still think Will would be a better first lynch on the basis that yorkie and ice together is unlikely. (You seem to have eliminated yorkie from your suspect list; is there a reason for that?)

What it boils down to, I think, is: if we get town, we have a slim chance for the doctor to save us, in which case we probably win, or definitely lose otherwise. If we get the roleblocker, we win. If we get the godfather, we have probably a 3/4 chance of winning. (50/50 of getting an investigation, and 50/50 of lynching the right person even without an investigation.)

Still waiting for will and yorkie to throw in their lots before I vote.

I wonder who the scum tried to kill last night....it would be helpful if we knew. I wonder if the doc would care to tell who was protected

I would think that was deducible. The only way the mafia could prevent an investigation was by killing one and blocking the other. Skoffin was under more suspicion than ET, hence more likely to get lynched, so they blocked her and tried to eat ET. Doc worked out what was going to happen, protected ET.

So ET is cleared by virtue of almost getting eaten, and skoffin is cleared by virtue of not having tried to eat ET.

*by killing one of the two claimed power roles and blocking the other.

Phil, I must say whether you are scum or not you have made some very good observations that make a lot of sense.

So are we now presuming scffin and et to be town?

Just an observation, but if skoffin was scum she would have to claim being blocked surely? But I think we can clear ET now as I suspect you are right about him being eaten last night. That being the case had skoffin been scum wouldn't et have tracked him to et's house in his attempt to eat him? Yet ET says skoffin didn't move.

Icedagger cannot be ruled out. He may have complained privately to the mods regarding cena being lynched after the deadline. Certainly if I was scum I would have done what Icedagger did.

William too voted Cena, but he may have been waiting for cena to claim before 'believing' him. He could have been outdone by cena claiming late and in effect being speed lynched by me and dagger. Out of all the players william has behaved more like scum than anybody

I don't want to vote him at the moment as I don't want to give scum a chance to speed lynch him

Phil is looking more and more like town, but that may just be cos he is playing a clever game. I know skoffin cleared him but they may yet be scum buddies or phil may be godfather.

Skoffin I don't know what you're talking about with me backing off you "now I can't get a lynch".. I said yesterday if Iliad turns out town it likely clears you and ET. As for the case against me, it seems to be built on william following me around, and me hammering scum. I really don't get where you're coming from on it.

So I think by process of deduction yorkie and will must be our scum.. my only problem with this is will's claim. He said-

Im Evan, a vanilla townie. I came here because my friend got dumped and she wants me to come along on the trip.

Can anyone counterclaim/confirm if this is why Evan's there? It just seems like a pretty good claim. Also has Yorkie claimed yet?

It's true as far as it goes. Yorkie's claim (way back on page 35) was:
Look, my name is Richard but everyone calls me Rich. I suppose you could say I am a bit of a loner but I love hiking. I have come here simply to climb bear mountain and really don't know a thing about these cannibals.
Which is also true, but a really minor character. You know how horror films often open with a character who gets killed straight away? Their only importance to the film is for their disappearance to be unexplained. That's Rich.

Will's said he'll be offline for a couple of days, so it looks like we're stuck waiting for now if we want him to put in his thoughts. I guess I'll give until tuesday night before I vote if he hasn't returned.

philh wrote:I still think Will would be a better first lynch on the basis that yorkie and ice together is unlikely. (You seem to have eliminated yorkie from your suspect list; is there a reason for that?)

Ha I still think Yorkie could be perhaps scum, but the other two have been more in the spotlight for me I'm certain atleast one out of will and ice are scum so I've been more concerned with them. And I only trust you because of my investigation

philh wrote:I would think that was deducible. The only way the mafia could prevent an investigation was by killing one and blocking the other. Skoffin was under more suspicion than ET, hence more likely to get lynched, so they blocked her and tried to eat ET.

Heh, that's pretty much what I assumed would happen after I claimed.


Will's gone huh? That is not good, don't we have a deadline? Speaking of, roughly how much time do we have left? (I am no good at figuring out timezones)

84 Hours.

Announcement

Rebelman has replaced william18.

confirm, got my role, am reading the thread now

as will's replacement i concur with will's earlier claim

Skoffin wrote:Well, if you were scum you'd also have to concur with it

I take it you've read up then? Have any thoughts on anyone yet?

i will post anon with my thoughts, got a bit distracted

Well we'd better get on otherwise we will end up with a no lynch.

vote rebelman

vote count pls mods.

Vote Count

Icedagger: (1) Skoffin
Rebelman: (1) Yorkiepeter

It is 11:45 here, which means there is 9 hours and 15 minutes left before the deadline.

With 6 alive, it is 4 to lynch.