Conquer Club

Great good going guys, we pretty much have no choice now.

unvote vote rebel

I have recieved a request for deadline extension due to the large forum downtime, which I think is perfectly reasonable, I was unable to access them at all yesterday.

I'll talk to Mili.

Announcement

The deadline has been extended two days due to the forum being unavailable on wednesday.

It is now Saturday 9 pm Gmt.

yorkiepeter wrote:I wonder who the scum tried to kill last night....it would be helpful if we knew. I wonder if the doc would care to tell who was protected

I just noticed this after reading through a bit.. this is incredibly scummy and I'm suprised no one else picked up on it!

Vote yorkiepeter

icedagger wrote:

yorkiepeter wrote:I wonder who the scum tried to kill last night....it would be helpful if we knew. I wonder if the doc would care to tell who was protected

I just noticed this after reading through a bit.. this is incredibly scummy and I'm suprised no one else picked up on it!

Vote yorkiepeter

Its all very well accusing me of being scummy, but why?

I think has as been explained it would appear that ET was protected and therefore they tried to kill ET, which presumably clears ET. Please tell why trying to clear someone is scummy.

As the deadline as been extended unvote for now. I don't want to give the 2 scum left a chance to speed lynch rebel before we here what he has to say.

Vote Count


Rebelman: (2) Yorkiepeter, skoffin
Yorkiepeter: (1) Icedagger

With 6 alive, it is 4 to lynch.

icedagger wrote:I just noticed this after reading through a bit.. this is incredibly scummy and I'm suprised no one else picked up on it!

Except at this point, being able to clear a suspect is worth more than the scum not knowing who the doc is. If I didn't think ET had been protected last night, I'd still be wondering about him, and by extension skoffin. Whereas the scum can't do anything about the doc without giving us a free investigation, which is a risk they may not be willing to take. The knowledge wouldn't be totally useless, but it wouldn't be a death sentence for us.

I don't trust rebelman's delaying. But I didn't trust Iliad's delaying either, so I'll keep waiting for now.

Anyway the two things holding me back from voting Rebelman are- 1) I'm not sure Will would be able to fake that claim- it doesn't read like something he wrote. Of course I could just be underestimating Will here. and 2) Yorkie voting for him- from my point of view with two scum left Will (now rebel) would have to be partnered with Skoffin, ET or phil if not scum, all of who have seemingly been cleared.

So assuming Yorkie's vote was not a ploy, this brings me to-

1) A yorkie-phil partnership with phil being godfather
2) a rebelman-phil partnership with phil being godfather
3) Skoffin is lying, and is scum presumbably with ET

I'm actualy gonna backtrack a bit here and change my mind about the doctor thing. I think he's probably going to have to come out today, but it will be worth it for a mafia lynch. I say this because-

Skoffin and ET have both claimed other town power roles so can be ruled out as doctor.

This leaves me, rebel, yorkie and phil.

First, the possibility that phil's doctor. If he is, I want Skoffin to tell us, as this would confirm her as cop and Phil as town leaving us (from my perspective) with rebel and yorkie as scum.
Next me- here's where I claim- I am Halley and I came here to climb Bear mountain. I'm a vanilla townie.
So if Skoffin doesn't confirm phil as doctor, this leaves us with yorkie and rebelman. Whichever of these is doctor, by process of elimination, the other one must be scum. From your point of view they could be scum partners with me, but if this happens I will know Phil must be mafia godfather.

So for these reasons I think the doctor should claim, but if phil is the doctor let skoffin do it for you. If the doctor claims but protected someone other than ET and Skoffin last night, this puts them back as suspects.

Whew long post but I think it all maskes sense..

nice post ice and i dont know will at all but he was v honest in his post i may change my vote but for now unvote vote yorkie

icedagger wrote:Anyway the two things holding me back from voting Rebelman are- 1) I'm not sure Will would be able to fake that claim- it doesn't read like something he wrote. Of course I could just be underestimating Will here. and 2) Yorkie voting for him- from my point of view with two scum left Will (now rebel) would have to be partnered with Skoffin, ET or phil if not scum, all of who have seemingly been cleared.

It's not that great a claim. And I think there's a good chance the scum have a roster of who is and isn't in the game, giving them two safe claims. Or at least something along those lines. They kinda need an advantage against a town with more power roles (cop, tracker, joat, doc) than they have members.

First, the possibility that phil's doctor. If he is, I want Skoffin to tell us, as this would confirm her as cop and Phil as town leaving us (from my perspective) with rebel and yorkie as scum.

I was under the impression that cops only detected scum/town, not actual powers. I won't say any more on this matter until skoffin confirms or denies that though.

Rebelman, you're voting yorkie in agreement with one of icedagger's points that he has since backtracked on. Need I say more?

Forgot to Unvote

In all games I've been in cops get the role of the person they're investigating

i said i thought ice made a nice post - not that i agree with it also i said i may change my vote - this gae is nearly over and im joining it late in the day. Anyway for now:

unvote

Well, because Ice seems to want it, my claim: I am Jessie Burlingame, the hot female lead. My friends brought me on a road trip here to help get over my boyfriend breaking up with me.

I'm a mini-JOAT. I get one investigation or night kill or protection in the game. I also knew that Chris was JOAT (but not who he was), what he did each night, and the result of his own investigation. Unfortunately he didn't do anything.

So, not doc. But I did protect ET last night, and I suspect that was all we're getting.

I agree with skoffin. Will and Rebel both followed ice around ("nice post ice - vote yorkie... *ice unvotes*... I never said I agreed with it - unvote"), and he's acting almost like he wants to protect them while not coming down too strong in his defense. It's not at all concrete, but I think I'm going to vote rebelman shortly unless someone gives me a compelling reason not to.

So have you used your investigation/night kill at all phil?

icedagger wrote:So have you used your investigation/night kill at all phil?

he said he gets 1 nightkill OR 1 investigation OR 1 protection. As he claims to have protected ET last night, I guess he has no more powers.

Missed that. Well if no one claims doc that pretty much clears phil I guess.

Which leaves us with me yorkie and rebelman.

Vote Rebelman

It doesn't look like we're getting any more information.

Vote rebelman.

Yeah I thought so all along

vote rebalman

Vote Count

Icedagger (2) skoffin, Yorkie
Rebel (3) Icedagger, Philh, ET

Not voting (1) Rebel

6 alive, 4 to lynch.

Ouch, fastposted!

That's a lynch!

Lots of accusations fly around, until finally it settles on one person. As more people turn on him he gets more aggresive...Yorkie drags him up to the gallows, and as it starts to get dark, he is hung.

Rebelman/William18 - Evan (Vanilla Townie) is dead.

As you stare at the lifeless, limp body, you think to yourself, that your time has come.

It is night 5.

gahhh i didnt think will coudlve faked that claim..