Game 11077825 Whyareyouhere? and McLardin [Cleared] DCR

[orangeblssmspcl]

Accused:

581388/Whyareyouhere?
577335/McLardin



The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy




Game number(s):

11077825 Europe 1914
possibly other games, but this one is the one I know there was secret diplomacy.



Comments: Early in the game, red and green make a deal not to attack one another. So far, no problem as it is in the chat. Once they have one by one eliminated almost all the other players, there is a three way situation in which whyareyouhere? has the overwhelming lead and logic dictates McLardin attack. At this point, McLardin puts in comment section:
2012-05-31 21:51:16 - McLardin: pearl harbor green
2012-06-01 08:10:58 - Whyareyouhere?: haha, understood
After which red makes no attacks the following turns, allowing green to take game. They play a high number of games together, not as doubles, but as individuals where they seem to be taking out other players.

[Jdsizzleslice]

Accused:

581388/[player]Whyareyouhere?[/player]
577335/[player]McLardin[/player]



The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy




Game number(s):

Game 11077825 Europe 1914
possibly other games, but this one is the one I know there was secret diplomacy.



Comments: Early in the game, red and green make a deal not to attack one another. So far, no problem as it is in the chat. Once they have one by one eliminated almost all the other players, there is a three way situation in which whyareyouhere? has the overwhelming lead and logic dictates McLardin attack. At this point, McLardin puts in comment section:
2012-05-31 21:51:16 - McLardin: pearl harbor green
2012-06-01 08:10:58 - Whyareyouhere?: haha, understood
After which red makes no attacks the following turns, allowing green to take game. They play a high number of games together, not as doubles, but as individuals where they seem to be taking out other players.

Fixed the links

[vodean]

that SOUNDS pretty public... there may be more to it though, based on that... im not sure. i dont think its SD. just foe them.

[agentcom]

that SOUNDS pretty public... there may be more to it though, based on that... im not sure. i dont think its SD. just foe them.

You can't collude to hand games to one another even if you put it in chat. I don't know if that's what's actually happening here, but just putting things in chat doesn't mean there's no cheating going on.

[deathcomesrippin]

Whyareyouhere? and McLarin are Cleared of Secret Diplomacy.