a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

Have any bright ideas? Share and discuss them with the community

Moderator: Community Team

Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.

And don't forget to search for previously suggested ideas first!
Post Reply
User avatar
t4mcr53s2
Posts: 925
Joined: Wed Sep 21, 2011 1:19 pm
Gender: Male
Location: maryland, usa

a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

Post by t4mcr53s2 »

a tournement of mirrored games were player A goes first on map 1 vs player B and player B goes first on mirrored drop on map A
if this needs clarification, imagine any one vs one game where you went first ; you play that game and the exact same map and drop except your opponent has your drop and goes first ... those are mirrored games ... perhaps a tournament round would be 6 pairs of mirrored games against your opponent ,:
  • probably easiest to do by scenario ; but maybe a coder thinks it could be done on a random map and random drop
would require red always going first so team A or player A in 1 v 1 starts half the mirrored games , as does team B :
  • could start times be staggered , so player A and B receive half their red games day one , and the mirrored half day 2 to allow them equal opportunity to see and copy vs improve their opponents start strategy?
in the 1 vs 1 championships even in 25 or 27 game matches I've had significant advantages in drops and getting first turns i think...
caveat; of course is still the luck of players familarity with random map or scenario and dice... also tneed to consider a tiebreaker ; e.g. fewest turns in victories , or a single game that isn't mirrored. or the way auto-tournaments are settled now ; first to join wins (@#$%) ! :
    I wish either my father or my mother, or indeed both of them as they were in duty both equally bound to it, had minded what they were about when....

    If 2 player fog game,please allow 12 hour snap courtesy, or post what I could have seen.... Thank you
    User avatar
    concrete
    Posts: 876
    Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 10:01 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: Highest score...3251 /#49 .... sitters: RKCVED

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by concrete »

    So if "mirrored games" is offered as a game option and you click it when you are creating a game, then another player selects to play it in waiting games, that player who selects it is actually signing up to play 2 games against you. In game 1, player 1 goes 1st, then in 2nd game player 2 goes 1st. If that is what your saying then I like the idea. That is a great option to have when creating games. I would think that it would be easy to implement not only in 1 vs 1 games but every other setting as well. NOT JUST TOURNEY'S, regular games would work out great with this option!!!
    User avatar
    IcePack
    Multi Hunter
    Multi Hunter
    Posts: 16851
    Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2010 6:42 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: California

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by IcePack »

    Theoretically you can set this up using scenarios can't you? Specify territories for red / green and then in your tournament set up two games, and alternate who's red?
    Image

    fac vitam incredibilem memento vivere
    Knowledge Weighs Nothing, Carry All You Can
    User avatar
    Donelladan
    Posts: 3691
    Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 8:48 am

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Donelladan »

    It would work icepack. But it would be better if this could be coded as an option for any kind of maps, and with a random drop.

    Simply like that, first game is generated normally with a random drop. Second game is a copied of the first one, but both players are exchanged, and the same one start. And that for all maps.
    If possible also for team games.
    Image
    Lord_Bremen
    Posts: 147
    Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 12:22 am
    Gender: Male
    Location: Chicago

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Lord_Bremen »

    This is basically a home and away option, I like it.
    clangfield
    Posts: 601
    Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 6:57 am
    Gender: Male
    Location: Kent, UK

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by clangfield »

    concrete wrote:So if "mirrored games" is offered as a game option and you click it when you are creating a game, then another player selects to play it in waiting games, that player who selects it is actually signing up to play 2 games against you. In game 1, player 1 goes 1st, then in 2nd game player 2 goes 1st. If that is what your saying then I like the idea. That is a great option to have when creating games. I would think that it would be easy to implement not only in 1 vs 1 games but every other setting as well. NOT JUST TOURNEY'S, regular games would work out great with this option!!!
    How would that work in more than 1 v 1? In 3 player you'd need 6 games to get every combination of who goes in each position; 24 games for 4 players, and so on. Can't see it catching on for 12 player games.
    For 1 v 1 though, I like the idea. Just gets a bit tricky for a freemium with one game slot.
    User avatar
    IcePack
    Multi Hunter
    Multi Hunter
    Posts: 16851
    Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2010 6:42 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: California

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by IcePack »

    clangfield wrote:
    concrete wrote:So if "mirrored games" is offered as a game option and you click it when you are creating a game, then another player selects to play it in waiting games, that player who selects it is actually signing up to play 2 games against you. In game 1, player 1 goes 1st, then in 2nd game player 2 goes 1st. If that is what your saying then I like the idea. That is a great option to have when creating games. I would think that it would be easy to implement not only in 1 vs 1 games but every other setting as well. NOT JUST TOURNEY'S, regular games would work out great with this option!!!
    How would that work in more than 1 v 1? In 3 player you'd need 6 games to get every combination of who goes in each position; 24 games for 4 players, and so on. Can't see it catching on for 12 player games.
    For 1 v 1 though, I like the idea. Just gets a bit tricky for a freemium with one game slot.
    Premium only perk, problem solved.
    Image

    fac vitam incredibilem memento vivere
    Knowledge Weighs Nothing, Carry All You Can
    User avatar
    Dukasaur
    Community Team
    Community Team
    Posts: 28236
    Joined: Sat Nov 20, 2010 4:49 pm
    Location: Beautiful Niagara

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Dukasaur »

    IcePack wrote:
    clangfield wrote:
    concrete wrote:So if "mirrored games" is offered as a game option and you click it when you are creating a game, then another player selects to play it in waiting games, that player who selects it is actually signing up to play 2 games against you. In game 1, player 1 goes 1st, then in 2nd game player 2 goes 1st. If that is what your saying then I like the idea. That is a great option to have when creating games. I would think that it would be easy to implement not only in 1 vs 1 games but every other setting as well. NOT JUST TOURNEY'S, regular games would work out great with this option!!!
    How would that work in more than 1 v 1? In 3 player you'd need 6 games to get every combination of who goes in each position; 24 games for 4 players, and so on. Can't see it catching on for 12 player games.
    For 1 v 1 though, I like the idea. Just gets a bit tricky for a freemium with one game slot.
    Premium only perk, problem solved.
    Even with premium, it would probably be an uweildy solution. A six-player game wouldn't just require six games, it would require 6! games (every permutation of drop and start order.)

    I don't disagree with making it a premium perk, but it would still probably work best only with game types that could be mirrored with 2 games only -- 1v1s, polys, 4P dubs, 6P trips, and 8P quads.
    “‎Life is a shipwreck, but we must not forget to sing in the lifeboats.”
    ― Voltaire
    User avatar
    IcePack
    Multi Hunter
    Multi Hunter
    Posts: 16851
    Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2010 6:42 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: California

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by IcePack »

    Yeah my first solution would be to utilize scenarios.

    Other than that, premium perk I think would be required.
    Image

    fac vitam incredibilem memento vivere
    Knowledge Weighs Nothing, Carry All You Can
    User avatar
    Donelladan
    Posts: 3691
    Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 8:48 am

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Donelladan »

    In multiplayer game, drop and first turn are not so much a problem as in 1vs1.
    I agree with Dukausaur, this would be useful, and realistic, only in game with 2 teams ( 1vs1/2vs2/3vs3/4vs4/poly),
    In 6 players games I never care that I start or not so much with the drop.
    Image
    judge_reinhold
    Posts: 110
    Joined: Sun Sep 02, 2012 10:59 pm
    Location: meat
    Contact:

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by judge_reinhold »

    1v1 mirrored games would be cool.

    Maybe only make it available for players who have finished x number of games. Newbies get confused by all the options.
    User avatar
    jaybrake
    Posts: 8
    Joined: Sat Apr 23, 2011 1:35 pm

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by jaybrake »

    very good idea!
    User avatar
    concrete
    Posts: 876
    Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 10:01 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: Highest score...3251 /#49 .... sitters: RKCVED

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by concrete »

    My bad, I figured it was a given low #'s of players was better. So yes...awesome option for 1 vs 1, and poly. My love of the idea wasn't for 6 player games. Hopefully we'll see this as an option in game creation.
    codierose
    Posts: 1561
    Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2008 5:50 pm
    Gender: Male
    Location: RANDOMBULLSHIT.ORG
    Contact:

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by codierose »

    is it not a game of chance/luck
    User avatar
    Donelladan
    Posts: 3691
    Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 8:48 am

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Donelladan »

    A lot of tournaments try to eliminate the "luck part" by making best of 3, 5 or 7.
    In tournament the purpose is that the most skilled player win, not the luckiest.

    Therefore this would be a nice addition for tournaments.
    Image
    Vorpal Blade
    Posts: 12
    Joined: Mon Oct 14, 2013 5:54 pm
    Location: Virginia

    Re: a tournament that eliminates first turn and drop luck

    Post by Vorpal Blade »

    We are in Round 5 of New World 2 Masters and I find myself going second in 6 of the 9 games, it's hard to fight back from that starting point.

    I think poly levels the field more then the number of games.

    One other idea, some type of toggle where you get the drop or get to go first, but not both.

    The idea has challenges with fog of war, but it might help balance the playing field.
    Post Reply

    Return to “Suggestions”