TPA6 Shield & Signature Design Contest!

[dakky21]

well yeah, ronaldinho's design is clearly the best... but i got 2 places in top 5 LOL ! ... can I get a GA instead of credits? LOL?

btw.

rule #2 about signature states "The signature must include a copy of your actual cup image from the stamp picture (must be the same cup)."

If you can see the CUP in the Ronaldinho signature, then I'm blind.
And VI in signature but not in the small image. Not the same cup, but still in signature it's not the cup anyway.

Shannon's design is better according to the rules....

[dakky21]

Remind me next time to include one pixel of the cup so it is included in the signature.

[Ronaldinho]

Wow, nice job everyone.

[iAmCaffeine]

Wow, nice job everyone.

Quality job mate.

[Swifte]

That's a really nice cup - nice job ronaldinho!

[Shannon Apple]

I love it.

Well done, Ronaldinho.

[Dukasaur]

It is a rather beautiful piece of art. Still, I thought it was too much of a departure from tradition.

So now you know what we want:
The same, but different. Different, but the same. In other words, create a logo that is immediately recognizable as being in the same family as the others, but at the same time has a new and distinctive personality.

It certainly has a new and distinctive personality, but I'm not sure it's "immediately recognizable as being in the same family" as the others.

I scored it in the middle of the pack. High points for being very good-looking, but lowered because it's too far from the original. I guess the other judges thought otherwise.

[dakky21]

It is a rather beautiful piece of art. Still, I thought it was too much of a departure from tradition.

So now you know what we want:
The same, but different. Different, but the same. In other words, create a logo that is immediately recognizable as being in the same family as the others, but at the same time has a new and distinctive personality.

It certainly has a new and distinctive personality, but I'm not sure it's "immediately recognizable as being in the same family" as the others.

I scored it in the middle of the pack. High points for being very good-looking, but lowered because it's too far from the original. I guess the other judges thought otherwise.

And I still wonder about this rule:

We also have a set of guidelines governing signatures - these are in accordance with CC's general signature guidelines:
The signature must include a copy of your actual cup image from the stamp picture (must be the same cup).

There is no quote about changing it or cropping it, but well, what can be done now... they're breaking their own rules, what to say...

I agree Ronaldinho's shield & signature are the best, but it deviates from the rules.

[iAmCaffeine]

It's still recognisable as a Conquer Club design, I personally think that's good enough.

[Ronaldinho]

I take all the comments about my entry onboard. I guess if you're going by the letter then i've probably skimmed outside the guidelines given. I don't know what to say other than if you want me to edit my entry slightly then it's fine - But i'm guessing its all finalised etc. Don't know what else to say really.

[Dukasaur]

I take all the comments about my entry onboard. I guess if you're going by the letter then i've probably skimmed outside the guidelines given. I don't know what to say other than if you want me to edit my entry slightly then it's fine - But i'm guessing its all finalised etc. Don't know what else to say really.

Obviously a majority of judges loved it, so don't worry too much about the minority rumblings of a grumpy old man.


"See, you can't please everyone,
So you got to please yourself...."