[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

[Whatsausage]

I like the way 3 of my 5 votes so far are from the players I have questioned in this game (benga, twr, pt)
So keep that in mind if I am lynched or NK'd.

True, but why the anti=town result, then? That is my concern.

Well that statement was for town to analyze votes later in the game if I am killed.
Believe me, it is concerning for me too, as I don't know why that result came up

[Iron Butterfly]

I'm going to vote whatsausage. I hardly need to remind anyone that I'm skeptical of IB already, whereas I have less of a reason to distrust benga. IB's "oh btw I checked sausage" smacks of a lie made up on the spot to protect one of his scum/3P buddies.

Further vote test.

Unvote vote Mets

dont take it personally, I just think you will cope well with being used as a test subject

Indeed, as I was reading through I was hoping someone would do this. In fact, it gives me the idea to test the following:

unvote

vote whatsausage

Sounds like a great way to set me up if your scum and and bussing your buddy. It goes both ways.

[mtamburini]

Alright it's still early, so I don't have much for reads.
Storr is acting about how I normally expect, not sure how alignment indicative that is though, so I'll say slightly town

In a game this size, it is so incredibly easy for players to slide way under the radar.
I've seen this instituted in other large games, where each player has someone to keep track of to try and keep activity up. The easiest way seems to be the player below you on the signup list. For example, falko is below me, and he is yet to post after his confirmation post.

@Falko, care to join us?

I like you.

[mtamburini]

Marushu wrote : "Storr, are you town this game?

What sort of a question is that? Surely everyone would answer YES to such a Question be they Town/Mafia/first dog on Mars or whatever weird roles have been planned...

What did you hope to find out/advertise by asking this???

Storr sometimes claims 3P. This was my invite for him to do so. Now he's either town or mafia, because if he gets found out as not being town, we can hold him to this. That was my reasoning, anyway.

Below me in the list is... madmitch. Well, then.

fp'd by mitch, Storr

This is nonsense. First, Storr doesn't need anybody to ask him to claim; he'll claim if he feels like it. Second, of course if he's 3P and doesn't want to claim that yet, he's going to lie and say he's town. If he later claims 3P, we wouldn't lynch him just because he said now that he's town.

Sounds like more ass kissing to me

[Metsfanmax]

I'm going to vote whatsausage. I hardly need to remind anyone that I'm skeptical of IB already, whereas I have less of a reason to distrust benga. IB's "oh btw I checked sausage" smacks of a lie made up on the spot to protect one of his scum/3P buddies.

Further vote test.

Unvote vote Mets

dont take it personally, I just think you will cope well with being used as a test subject

Indeed, as I was reading through I was hoping someone would do this. In fact, it gives me the idea to test the following:

unvote

vote whatsausage

Sounds like a great way to set me up if your scum and and bussing your buddy. It goes both ways.

If I am scum and you are telling the truth about being town, why the hell would I help throw out a scum buddy just to have a chance at lynching you later? You'd be way the hell down on my priority list.

[mtamburini]

Just adding thewarrior is below me only confirmation so far but still early

are you looking for town or looking for scum?

[mtamburini]

Sory, in all the eggsitement I fergot to mispel. It wont hapen agin.

Wouldn't that break your PR and resulting in some sort of punishment?

FOS

[mtamburini]

Skoffin is not traitor, she is just insane, sees in all others traitors, I would think she is town.

played with her before?

[mtamburini]

Got to page 14 where I first posted and got bored with the IB hotshot discussion bs, anything of interest that I should read.

[Metsfanmax]

How about the whole fucking thread because you're actually in this game. If you can't be bothered to participate in the game, have someone replace you.

[mtamburini]

How about the whole fucking thread because you're actually in this game. If you can't be bothered to participate in the game, have someone replace you.

Not before I shoot you in the face tonight

[StorrZerg]

f*ck you tambo. I wanted your claim yesterday

[mtamburini]

f*ck you tambo. I wanted your claim yesterday

Sucks to suck call my internet company

[StorrZerg]

I am Town "Insane Asylum Guard".

Ib your role caused a flipped check imo. This makes the most sense to me.


Lynching whatsausage will confirm how insane works with magic 8 ball. As well as benga.

Glad to have you back tambourine, read up on whatsausage

And Im town (checked by a cop)

We have 3 cops atm plus ib free check.
Pltwoe town checked me
Benga red checked whatsausage, he is retired cop, 2 checks. Used in day.
Ib green checked whatsausage with magic 8 ball used in day
Madmitch deputy, got Marashu "green" check of aladdin. (Marashu was insane, so AladdinSane is likely anti town. Waiting on madmitch to confirm.)

[Iron Butterfly]

You think I am insane and do not know it?

A tad confused on that.

[Metsfanmax]

Clearly madmitch isn't going to confirm, he had his opportunity. But there's problems here. First, to what extent is it likely that madmitch would get the results of Marashu's investigations? I've never played with a deputy before. Second, why would he have information on two players? And if he only has investigative results on one of them, we can't be sure that it was Aladdin and not Storr. Until madmitch clarifies, if ever, we can't really do much with his information.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

If someone was actually insane in the game they wouldn't "know it". IB just guarded the insane is how I'm reading it.
Mass claiming in a game like this trying to play the mod would be bad for town. Their are too many possible roles that mafia could "make up" that it would make it quite easy for them to try to pick off the town's power roles at night. After all, mafia would know what lies are fake that are getting used by mafia while town would be "naked" out there with what they can do.
Playing the mod by mass claiming usually doesn't end too well. I know in the games I've modded in the past when people would try to do that, it usually hastened their downfall.

Alladin is most likely a 3rd party spammer. I had that type of role once in a fircoal game. It sucked, but too "win" i had to have x number of posts in the game.

The magic 8 ball is suppose to be true according to what the mod told IB and it gave a town read on sausage so I am not voting him. With it being a one time use, it would be messed up in the inventor or whoever gave it an insane result type format. Vote White Rose because I think you're scum with how you're trying to guide town.

[mtamburini]

I am Town "Insane Asylum Guard".

Ib your role caused a flipped check imo. This makes the most sense to me.


Lynching whatsausage will confirm how insane works with magic 8 ball. As well as benga.

Glad to have you back tambourine, read up on whatsausage

And Im town (checked by a cop)

We have 3 cops atm plus ib free check.
Pltwoe town checked me
Benga red checked whatsausage, he is retired cop, 2 checks. Used in day.
Ib green checked whatsausage with magic 8 ball used in day
Madmitch deputy, got Marashu "green" check of aladdin. (Marashu was insane, so AladdinSane is likely anti town. Waiting on madmitch to confirm.)

I initially like What for bringing up the lets look at the person underneath us thing, would suck if he used that for easy town cred, but that would mean whoever is underneath him would not be his partner cause that would be illogical to bus for no reason and/or bring attention to a partner for no reason.

[rishaed]

I like the way 3 of my 5 votes so far are from the players I have questioned in this game (benga, twr, pt)
So keep that in mind if I am lynched or NK'd.

fp'd by rishaed

Just speculation, but could make sense
Any other thoughts beyond just throwing speculation out?

My other thoughts about topics have already been given earlier in the day. Even with all of the cops claiming I'm unsure of which direction we should go in. Storr is obviously pushing for the mass claim, but I don't think with a game like this with multiple rolls of the same thing we are actually going either A. Break the setup or B. Have a 100% Chance at catching scum.
I'm weighing pro's and con's. The other major con i see with mass claiming D2 is that Scum will then have a decent roadmap of who to target every night.

[Iron Butterfly]

Mass claiming is stupid.

Storr is not necessarily Town because he got a Town read from Ptlowe. Now of course Storr is going to say he is Town but so far all the cops reads have come into question.

With so many cops why the need for someone to pass out a magic 8 ball to make investigations?

Insane cop
Benga and I got opposite results on Sausage

I also tried to make this point earlier. I was TOLD who was scum. With so many cops why was that needed?My role could have just as easily been made where I had to guess who the escapee was.
I think my role was created to sow more confusion. I say HS is scum, he gets investigated, He comes back Town. I get lynched. You get the picture.

There was another game a while back with a gifter who gave out items that detect alignment. The gifter would all but be useless if the 8 Ball was wrong.It is also no coincidence that the gift is a cop check in a game full of cops.

[the white rose]

Vote White Rose because I think you're scum with how you're trying to guide town.

really? and what would make me look town? if i kept quiet, didn't contribute and posted once per day like you.....i am here playing the game, trying to find scum, sure i may be wrong, but i am doing the best i can, where as you hardly bother even trying.....and so i guess that makes you more town than me.....

[madmitch]

Did everyone receive there packages ? tick tock tick tock , better hurry up, only way to stop the delivery is stop the mailman hehehehe

[degaston]

Did everyone receive there packages ? tick tock tick tock , better hurry up, only way to stop the delivery is stop the mailman hehehehe

Are you the mailman?

[degaston]

Did everyone receive there packages ? tick tock tick tock , better hurry up, only way to stop the delivery is stop the mailman hehehehe

Are you the mailman?

And whether you are or not, why does he need to be stopped?

[madmitch]

Best for town if the packages never came, I AM mailman for now I.B. already received his package, I was told the rest are bad for town, I DON'T WANT TO DIE but it looks like I might half too to stop the deliveries, why me ? I just was starting to have fun.