For the record, I would put New Guy and Mets as likely town or at the least unlikely Team Rocket. Mets has done some other things that make me think he is town but to be relatively brief both Mets and New Guy voted Chu at a time when the votes were tied before that (Mets technically should be the vote before mine in chronological order) and it looked likely that whoever got an edge in votes first would be propelled towards the lynch. If Mitch was town and Chu scum they almost definitely wouldn't have voted for Chu at that point. If I am wrong and Mitch is scum than its still unlikely that they would have voted for the more useful scum member.
Disregarding the votes of the dead, where Tal Nag and Buj votes are the likely spots for scum to be on the wagon imo (though I would not dismiss Exile as possibly hammering for town cred). Nag had a rough start but his posts have improved in quality as the game has become more serious plus Chu tried to start a serious case on him to save his own skin so I believe he is town at this point. Tal and Buj voted late on the wagon at a point where (unless i am remember incorrec tly) chu had a two vote advantage over mitch and his lynch was little better than inevitable so it is a relatively easy spot to jump on to gain town credit. However I dont remember either one doing anything particularly scummy unless you count Buj's insistence on Dakky despite no counter claim abouto being Gary's pokemon which is a weak argument.
Based on Dakky being the fourth vote on Mitch it is possible if not likely that Gary could be one of the first three to vote Mitch and Dakky was following their lead. However, I would have to double check but I think dakky actually originally voted Mitch before one of them but had unvoted and later put his vote back on Mitch. Of course considering that I still believe Kwan, the first three also seems likely to include the scum voters on Mitch's wagon.
](./images/smilies/eusa_wall.gif "Brick wall"){kind=small}
. However, I am reading the level up comment totally different from you dakky. I think he is claiming level-up and assuming that his NK connected as he is reading himself in the description or at least his target died. I am going to go back and read the scene and see if I can find mention of Bulbasaur. 
