D5 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

[Loose Canon]

Agree that everyone should hold votes, especially Halrob.

Particularly waiting on rag right now, no coming more forward from me till rag does.

Hopefully will be soon because still a delicious game.

Probably more delicious than strike was to Lecter.

[Ragian]

Don't we get notifications when the day starts, damnit?!?!

Anyway...I don't understand self lynching without a purpose. Last game, I offered to lynch myself IF people would then lynch Son!c the next day. Darin just hammered himself without explanation, without pointing a finger, and without having participated too much in the game. That kind of blows, man.

Losing Charle is bad, but it does give us a cleared townie in halrob, which is good.

Hjelp seems to think that it can only be between me and Loose, and while I think Loose looks worse and worse, I'm not sure what makes hjelp discount himself. Or Devante for that matter. The classic scum LyLo game is to offer up two possibilities for scum and then when you lynch one of them, you go, "Ooops, must be the other one, then." And then scum wins. Very clever.

Now, we're five people left:
- Ragian: 1-shot bulletproof ascetic town
- Halrob: Cleared town by Charle (can't remember role because it was altered due to poisoning or something)
---
- Devante: Unknown
- Loose: Claimed cop (despite there being a dead cop already)
- Hjelp: Claimed analyst (a role that seems useless given that Charle never needed an analyst to get the right result)

Supposedly, we're looking for the last mafia guy and, I think, a 3rd party poisoner (but there hasn't been any poisoning as of late, so I don't know if that role just slipped away with Darin like halrob said...I haven't really read the poems...).

Given that we're that few left, there's no real reason not to reveal all roles, so here goes: I am 1-Shot Bulletproof Town Ascetic. This means that I have one night where I'm protected from all kills targeting me, and all other things targeting me that night (protection, investigation, etc.) will fail as roleblocked.

Now, Devante, can you tell us about your role?

[Ragian]

Gameplay wise, I think everything points to Loose. The lack of voting Devon looks really bad. Hjelp voted for Devon. And early, too. That's good.

[halrob64]

Supposedly, we're looking for the last mafia guy and, I think, a 3rd party poisoner (but there hasn't been any poisoning as of late, so I don't know if that role just slipped away with Darin like halrob said...I haven't really read the poems...).

Ragian, I was poisoned N2 but as I protected myself I wasn't killed, but I was reduced to vanilla town N3, not sure if I recover or not that's up to Sonic, that's why there was only 1 killing N2
I think Darin was the poisoner, I think the poems pointed to the possibility, I can't substantiate that, just a theory, there was only 1 killing N3 from shooting so it does point to no more poisoning but maybe that was blocked, so who knows.
I agree regarding jhelp's power, it only works it seems if a cop investigates a mafia person, so if the cops result came back as town jhelp would get no information.
It does not confirm if there is a cop or not so unless Loose had a guilty result then we won;t know. Not a lot of help to town.

[Ragian]

Why didn't Darin come up as town and poisoner, then? Usually, it's revealed upon death...

[halrob64]

I can't answer that, maybe he wasn't and the poisoner is still out there lying dormant or only had limited capability, that would mean someone else poisoned me N2

[halrob64]

I still have Loose as 3P and Lord of Chaos but maybe he will reveal his cop activity from last night

[SoN!c]

Since it's just 5 players left we are going to one real life week per game day..

DEADLINE D4 of the REID is set to LA QUEMA DEL DIABLO this SUNDAY DECEMBER 7th...

La Quema del Diablo (Burning of the Devil), on December 7th marks the start of the Christmas season and celebrates the triumph of good over evil!!

4 days, 18 hours, 45 minutes, 0 seconds until SUNDAY december 7th 2025 (Guatemala City time)

Spoiler

https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/t ... sive&csz=1

[halrob64]

I thought 1 shot bullet proof was usually for serial killers

[Loose Canon]

Ok so I got an innocent result on Devante
Have to assume that's correct.

So as far as I'm concerned Hjelp and ragian are 3p and mafia, can't work out which is which.

As far as everyone else is concerned I'm in the mix as probably either mafia or 3p.

[halrob64]

I think that would be the correct result Loose, if Devante can confirm his role that will fit with what I know

[Ragian]

I don't know why you'd think 1 shot bulletproof would usually be for serial killers. That ability is not alignment indicative.

Loose, why did you not reveal that till after I revealed my role? Were you looking to see who was the better candidate for your boat ride? Why did you choose to investigate Devante over the Scandinavians?

Also, notice how Loose is doing two things (kind of like hjelp): he's saying that Devante is not scum, but he leaves a tiny bit of wiggle room for himself by saying that he can't be sure.

[Loose Canon]

Since I'm L-2,
I'm town and my role is Sleepwalker. Added to that is

"Town Surveillance Analyst"

At the end of the night when all other night actions are in You receive anonymous (but 100% accurate) reports when a town investigator has hit scum, even when the investigation returned a false result due to Godfather immunity or framing to the investigator or other conditions that tampered with the the investigator's result (i.e., the investigator himself did not actually detect scum) BUT only if the investigator survives the night. The investigator needs to be alive to file the report.

Once per game you can audit a killed investigators action to see what the result of the investigator was (works only on tracker and cop roles)..

Important:

The report is anonymous: it will not say which investigator performed the action that triggered the report.
The report does not reveal the identity of the scum-targeted player — only that a scum was succesfully targeted by investigator action(s) that night.
The Analyst's check uses true alignment, not investigation output. In other words, the Analyst triggers only when an investigator actually visited a Mafia member, regardless of what the investigator’s read looked like.
If an investigator was roleblocked before acting, or their visit was redirected so they did not actually target a scum, that does not count (no report).

I didn't get any report N1.
[/quote]

Hjelp you 1 get a report if cop hits baddun but not otherwise and 2 you get a report on investigations of a dead cop.
2 overlaps 1 and so would be pointless.
Unless this is 3p role you have adapted to say is town.

Think you are 3p and ragian is mafia

[Loose Canon]

Response to rag is the onus was on you to reveal first.

I'm not 100% that my results are correct, could be being fed then by 3p.

But wriggle room if you like my mafia matie

[halrob64]

Once per game you can audit a killed investigators action to see what the result of the investigator was (works only on tracker and cop roles)..

Presumably there is a report on who Charle was investigating?

[Ragian]

Response to rag is the onus was on you to reveal first.

I'm not 100% that my results are correct, could be being fed then by 3p.

But wriggle room if you like my mafia matie

Look, I appreciate your attempt, but you know just as well as me that my game play shows that I'm town while yours doesn't. 1) I was on the Devon lynch while you weren't, 2) I spent all D3 asking everyone to be patient and cautious lest we'd end in a speed lynch. What did you do D3? What have you done during the game apart from:
- Not counterclaiming all the cop claims (did we have three?)
- Gun so hard for the 3rd party that you obscured/polluted the thread
- Failed to vote for you fellow scummate

Fill in the gaps, my friend.

[Devante]

Supposedly, we're looking for the last mafia guy and, I think, a 3rd party poisoner (but there hasn't been any poisoning as of late, so I don't know if that role just slipped away with Darin like halrob said...I haven't really read the poems...).

Ragian, I was poisoned N2 but as I protected myself I wasn't killed, but I was reduced to vanilla town N3, not sure if I recover or not that's up to Sonic, that's why there was only 1 killing N2
I think Darin was the poisoner, I think the poems pointed to the possibility, I can't substantiate that, just a theory, there was only 1 killing N3 from shooting so it does point to no more poisoning but maybe that was blocked, so who knows.
I agree regarding jhelp's power, it only works it seems if a cop investigates a mafia person, so if the cops result came back as town jhelp would get no information.
It does not confirm if there is a cop or not so unless Loose had a guilty result then we won;t know. Not a lot of help to town.

I’ll fill in more of my role now that quack is gone. Was a major inference with my conditions. One question though Hal, at what point did you know you were poisoned?

[Devante]

And I expected that the quack would be scum not a town role so that being opposite and then daring also hammering himself does not sit right with me

[halrob64]

I’ll fill in more of my role now that quack is gone. Was a major inference with my conditions. One question though Hal, at what point did you know you were poisoned?

At the start of N3 I asked a question regarding what night action I could take, I received the information then, I had been poisoned N2 and was unfit for duty, my duties were taken over
for the night

[Loose Canon]

Yes you can and would colour it as bad on me, not too difficult is it?

On the other hand Rag what exactly is it about your claimed role, that you couldn't claim it D3?
Your claimed 1 shot ascetic is NO USE TO TOWN AT ALL - just if true protects and disguises yourself.
And if not true protects and disguises yourself.

At least all circumstantial evidence on me is stuff I've said yes true to.

Fpd

[Devante]

I’ll fill in more of my role now that quack is gone. Was a major inference with my conditions. One question though Hal, at what point did you know you were poisoned?

At the start of N3 I asked a question regarding what night action I could take, I received the information then, I had been poisoned N2 and was unfit for duty, my duties were taken over
for the night

Alright that lines up with what I know. I was notified that the real doc was poisoned but did not know he was poisoned. Hence I had to find the real doc and also from game start knew a quack doctor was in play which was why my digging in earlier days. I also knew because of the poisoning that the reason 3p was not successful in killing the doc was that doc had self protected that night. Hence darins claims of doc actions did not line up but yours did.

FP LC

[Devante]

And i'm not sure how mod will act if I claim my role specifically, this goes back to conditions that were highlighted beginning of game, so have to be careful so myself and Hal are not killed by a statement I make. What I think I can say without stating my role is that when I was notified about the doc being poisoned and unaware I focused on locating the real and quack doc so I could heal the poison of the real doc so he could remain in play. Don't kill us Sonic

[Devante]

jhelp I was not asking you to divulge the result, i was asking you if you had a result

There is a reason why not answer to you question yet.

There can be zero Town Cop - then I won't get any report.
There can be one Town Cop and If Town Cop investigated - then I will get a report, otherwise not.
There can be two Town Cops and If at least one Town Cop investigated - then I will get a report, otherwise not.

So for now not divulging.

anything to add at this point hjelp since it seems like your still withholding night info

[halrob64]

by Devante » Tue Dec 02, 2025 11:45 am

And i'm not sure how mod will act if I claim my role specifically, this goes back to conditions that were highlighted beginning of game, so have to be careful so myself and Hal are not killed by a statement I make. What I think I can say without stating my role is that when I was notified about the doc being poisoned and unaware I focused on locating the real and quack doc so I could heal the poison of the real doc so he could remain in play. Don't kill us Sonic

That all tallies with what I know, I can confirm I did know I had been poisoned.
I do know what you role is Devante although you have not been named to me I put two and two together when I was told the tole of the person standing in for me.
Unless forced to do so I don't think we need to reveal that.

[halrob64]

Sorry I did not know I had been poisoned until I asked the question N3 so that tallies with what you say